The Riddler

[Rottingham]

He ate his apple before he got there. So everyone else had their apple

sorry that's incorrct... good guess, though

He had only purchased 18 apples for 19 people (Because he's garrosh and he sucks...), however everyone was able to eat. What did Thrall decide to do?

[Saturo]

Split one apple?

[Rottingham]

Split one apple?

close, very close, but no cigar

[Saturo]

Order a Mage to conjure more apples?

[Rottingham]

sorry, no... you were closer with the splitting.

[Saturo]

You split Garrosh into two at the neck.

[Kaleos]

Take 3 apples and split them into fourths, each leader and Garrosh gets 3 pieces from this and then 15 left over for all the body guards?

[Rottingham]

That would be a nice way to solve it, but sadly, not what Thrall did. Lets just say that everyone got an even amount.

[Bulletdance]

Hmmm. I'd say Varian bursts into the room and kills Garrosh thus allowing the horde to realize how awesome he is and form a peace between them. Then they can have all the apples in the farm outside stormwind. lol jk. jk.

Did he cut all the apples in half and just give everyone one half saving the rest as a gift to varian cause he's so awesome?

[Rottingham]

Close... and that first one is an ending I like better then mine... However lets just say that the alliace in general are just out of this riddle... for now XD

Think about what you can do with apples if your teeth hurt (I might have given the answer away right there...)

[Bulletdance]

Ohhhh I see! Garrosh (being the stoopid hit things that don't work type) gets made because Thrall says no apples for you! And he smashes them all up with his ogreish hands flinging equal amounts of applesauce onto all there...then likely being killed by Slyvannis...cause damn that is a new outfit and we ladies all know how expensive those are.

[Rottingham]

Applesauce is the correct answer good job!