Here are the pets I currently have in mind.
Any or all, not sure yet - the white striped is the Night Elf starter pet; all three pets match a mount available to Night Elves.
Probably only one of the three - because of the owl scout some Night Elf units could summon. Ban'thalos would match closest, but he requires level 85 and would be my third Ban o_O The next closest match would be the ghostly jade owl, and it's also the most low-level, but I'm not sure I like it nearly as much as Olm or Ban.
Tortolla.
Goldrinn.
Probably only one, not both. Brown for Ursol/Ursoc, while white would be Grimclaw (if you've quested in Darkshore you'll know him). That is, if I can bring myself to actually like the bear models - they just bug me.
Aviana (closest I can get).
Lady Sathrah (from a Night Elf quest in Teldrassil).
Critter moths like this show up in Hyjal, and the larger, tamable version is from Azuremyst - it fits.
I'm out of ideas, though, and I have a feeling I'm missing a lot of potential pets. The only pet family I absolutely can't see a Night Elf wanting to tame are Silithids, due to the War of the Shifting Sands, but I can't see any pets that shout out "oooh, me, tame me" when looking at other families.
Thoughts?








