Castile wrote:This might sound bizzare but do you think she lured her back and maybe kept her inside so she couldn't get back to you? This woman sounds like she wants to keep your cat and the fact she wants you to tell the vet that she's now her cat makes me very suspicious - if you found someones cat and knew who it belonged to don't you think you'd tell them? If you keep cats indoors for 2 weeks or so they associate that as their home...I would take her back. She's your beloved pet, if this woman wants a cat she can go rescue one. She sounds like a freak tbh.Snowy wrote:I know. :/ And I've said this to my mum. The other problem is that my mum has work now, which means she's out all day and the other cats would be the only ones keeping her company a lot of the time. When we brought her back the first time, the other two remembered her so there's no problem there. It's all up to my mum and... whatever decision she goes with, I'll support that, but I can't say I won't be disappointed if she decides to let her keep her, but I'll also feel guilty if we bring her back and she's not as happy as she was... Even if she's getting overfed, she was happy, and taking her from one house to another and back again will no doubt confuse her a little. That's also probably part of the reason she left again.
Another, slightly more petty thing that bothers me is that this woman called her Nancy when she found her, and whenever she speaks to us she refers to her as Nancy and *urg*... thanks to her, I can't stand that name. She's OUR cat and she's called POPPY. Not Nancy. She would be dead without this woman's help, so I thank her for that, but ever since then she's gotten it into her head that Poppy belongs to her and... urg, piss off. :/
Honestly if she has other cats for company thats enough for them. They don't need people all the time like a dog. Cats are solitary creatures. We have 2 cats and I work all day, they seem very happy just being with each other. They only get upset when we both go on holiday but during the day they are fine. They are also indoor cats so maybe its time Poppy became one too
^^ This, so much this!!!!! A person who steals anothers cat from a loving home, cannot be thinking whats in the best interest of the cat. That she not only stole the cat once (resulting in Poppy being in poor fitness/health) but has now stolen her again!?!
I'd personally get Poppy back from her captor, and call the police to report the woman for theft!!! Stealing is NOT ok, it is NOT fine, and letting her Keep Poppy is telling her that what she did was Alright and who's to say she won't do it again with another person's furry family member?