Page 1 of 2

It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2011 5:51 pm
by Mania
From Sanya Weather's blog Eating Bees:
If you’re young and LGBT, I want you to know that gaming is getting better. In any community that I run, you will not be called names if you choose to be open about your identity and orientation. I will not allow the use of homophobic slurs, either at you or near you. I will not work for an employer who does not have my back on this. My forums are a safe place where you are not “other.” You are not alone. You are, always and forever, one of us.
That's her pledge, and it's mine as well. If you see *anything* that goes against this intention, please report it.

Aside: The whole post is well worth reading.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2011 6:01 pm
by Silivren
That makes me tear up.. My sister is gay and I love her very much.. I've helped her through the vile things people do say and I respect you highly for this Mania.. :hug:

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2011 6:44 pm
by Morven
Thank you for this, Mania. Both in your own pledge and in linking this post, which is worth reading.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2011 7:07 pm
by GormanGhaste
I haven't run into this on these forums, but have occasionally see it in guild chat when I am in larger guilds. I always responded politely with, "Please do not use the word gay in a negative way." Which usually takes care of it, but officers have always backed me up if it didn't. I really should do more reporting of trade chat, though. Blizzard just gives the impression that they don't do anything about it, which is bad PR on their part.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2011 7:30 pm
by Rhyela
My family is very homophobic, and when I was younger, I was, too. It was the way I was raised. But, I'm an adult now, and I can make my own decisions. I may not fully agree with or endorse LBGT lifestyles, but darn it, that doesn't mean I have a right to treat them as anything less than another thinking, feeling human being. Difference of opinion is going to happen no matter where you look, be it orientation, religion, political views, etc. You don't have to support or agree with someone else does, but they have every bit the same right as you do to feel the way they do.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, I'm not gay, but that doesn't mean I'm in any way better than someone who is. I don't understand why we all can't just let each other live life the way we want to live it, as long as it does not cause bodily, mental or emotional harm to others.

So, kudos to you for posting that link Mania. It's sad the way human beings treat other human beings just because we aren't all identical. How boring would that be, anyway? Amirite? :D

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2011 11:47 pm
by Aeladrine
I'm rather glad to see this.(: Making the internet a better place, one forum at a time!

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2011 11:51 pm
by Lotusii
That's very comforting Mania and thank you. I'm glad to see something like this here. I've not seen a problem with it here, but this is nice all the same.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2011 1:01 am
by Moore
'Like' <3

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2011 1:37 am
by Nubhorns
Image

<3

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2011 2:11 am
by Aritria
*Hugs Nubs*

As one who has identifier and supporter of the LGBTQ community, thank you for posting this. I know that this can be a safe place where gender slurs will be dealt with in an authoritative manner. Much love, Mania.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2011 8:18 am
by Wain
Yes, thank you for this :) No matter how many heated arguments start on these forums, I've always felt the people here were pretty open and accepting :)

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2011 10:42 am
by Royi
Wain wrote:Yes, thank you for this :) No matter how many heated arguments start on these forums, I've always felt the people here were pretty open and accepting :)
just not of Gnomes as Hunters unfortunately :(


But yeah at least with all the debate / heat / flamming that goes on here from time to time, I don't recall a time where gender / identity / orientation ever was an issue. I like that about these forums.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2011 10:11 pm
by Rhyela
That's because we're awesome!

Image

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 12:16 pm
by Tufak

We have a strong no harassment policy, which has led to a large number of both characters and players with alternate lifestyles joining the guild because we're 'safe'. Are you willing to maintain that policy and refrain from using derogatory terms relating to gender or sexual orientation both in guild and in places where you represent us, such as instances, parties, etc?
This is an actual question from the guild interview checklist for the guild that I run. We have members from all walks of life and our guild has even gotten a reputation as a 'safe haven' for differing sexualities via word of mouth.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 3:37 pm
by AdamSavage
Is it ok to say stuff like "that's gay" in reference to something one doesn't like ? It's meaning is not in any way aimed at the gay community at all. It's basically means that's stupid/lame/dumb etc etc.

Moderation note (edited in place for a fast answer, repeated below):

No, it's not okay. Please read the community rules post Getting Picky About Words:

There are a handful of words that get used a lot as slang in gaming, but that should not be used as slang on these forums.

Gay:
Yes: Pertaining to, related to, or indicating homosexuality.
No: Bad, stupid, silly, etc.


(The rest of your post is off-topic and has been edited out.)

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 3:52 pm
by Royi
Moore wrote:
AdamSavage wrote:Is it ok to say stuff like "that's gay" in reference to something one doesn't like ? It's meaning is not in any way aimed at the gay community at all. It's basically means that's stupid/lame/dumb etc etc. If your flat out insulting the person for being gay, that that's different. I don't see why people need to shelter everyone because "someone might take offense to that" It's like how we can't even say "Merry Christmas" anymore.. It's "happy holiday" and it's all because a couple people complained.
You're SERIOUSLY asking this? :|
So then in other words, its ok to say "stop being Jewish!" to people too?

ugh...


*edit*
I guess instead of being astounded or upset about this post Adam, I'll try to inform you why thats an ignorant viewpoint (we all have them, i'm ignorant about a lot of things in life as well)

Its not because people complained, its because using the word in a mean-manner or maliciously by equating that gay=stupid is implying that you think gay people ARE stupid. Or that you dislike gay people in general simple because of their sexualities. Its like using the N word to a dark skinned human, or using the terms "thats jewish" or "i got gyped". By equating a whole sector of people with a word that means crap, dirty, stupid, screwed, means (whether you actually mean it or not) that you're equating that race/ethnicity/religion/ or gender with that bad word.

If for instance I would somehow start a trend of using the word "Canadian" instead of "sucks" like "boy this dinner is aweful, its really Canadian!" ~ How can people NOT take offense to that? Or if I would start using something that relevant to you (that you take pride in) "religion, state you're from, family heritage, etc" I can force something that you identify with into being a word with negative connotations ~

Overall, it IS sexist, racist, religisist, bigitist, basically it covers all the ISMS that are bad in the world.

We need to focus more on ending the isms, not promoting them:
Image

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 5:43 pm
by Nubhorns
AdamSavage wrote:Is it ok to say stuff like "that's gay" in reference to something one doesn't like ? It's meaning is not in any way aimed at the gay community at all. It's basically means that's stupid/lame/dumb etc etc. If your flat out insulting the person for being gay, that that's different. I don't see why people need to shelter everyone because "someone might take offense to that" It's like how we can't even say "Merry Christmas" anymore.. It's "happy holiday" and it's all because a couple people complained.
It's not that you're directly insulting a gay person, it's that you're attaching further negative stigma to the word by using it as a synonym for stupid. The fact of the matter is that the term, as far as I can tell, originated in that manner as an insult to the LGBT community and even if you don't mean it as such, the implications are still there and in that case, no, it's not okay. If you're truly displeased with something there are quite a few other words you can use that are a darn sight more creative, at any rate. :P

For the record, I'm inclined to agree with you on several points. I believe that a great deal of the grief from slurs comes from the force put behind them. Like you said, the difference between saying "that's gay" and actually insulting a gay person - the feeling behind it. But it is still tasteless no matter how you look at it and, personally, I'd rather not see it on these forums.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 6:34 pm
by Silivren
I'm not sure why one couldnt just say "Thats stupid/dumb/lame" in the first place.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 6:37 pm
by AdamSavage
Then one could argue on the same concept that saying that's "stupid, dumb, retarded" is insulting towards mentally handicapped people. Was it mean to insult them ? Of course it's not, the word has more then one meaning to.

Re: It Gets Better, and It Begins With Us

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 6:38 pm
by GormanGhaste
This question has already been specifically addressed in the forum rules:
There are a handful of words that get used a lot as slang in gaming, but that should not be used as slang on these forums.
Gay:
Yes: Pertaining to, related to, or indicating homosexuality.
No: Bad, stupid, silly, etc.
assault:
Yes: Sexual assault.
No: Casual reference to a win or loss.
Retard:
Yes: None.
No: Idiot, describing a person who is stupid, silly, ignorant, etc.
Fat & related words:
Yes: Describing the physical state of a person or thing.
No: Making a moral judgement or expressing disrespect based on the physical state of a person or thing.

If any of these distinctions are unclear to you, remember this helpful guideline: If in doubt, leave it out!

And of course you are expected to avoid using derogatory or obscene language based on race, sex, gender, religion and so on. But I wanted to call out the slang above explicitly because these uses are so common in gaming.