Little White Lies?
Posted: Tue Aug 23, 2011 10:08 am
So.
I have a friend that fancies himself a writer and he's earnest and sincere and tries really, really hard...but he's not very good at all. His grammar is atrocious, his spelling horrible and his sentence structure weak at best. He -tries- and you can tell that he's trying, but most of what he writes is on the same level as what you might expect from a fourth or fifth grader, despite his being of college age.
And, since I write, he comes to me regularly seeking praise.
I've attempted to work with him. I've had some progress. After somebody left a scathing review of one of his stories on DeviantArt that left him in tears, I managed to get some improvement from him by convincing him to stop capitalizing letters in places where there's no reason whatsoever to capitalize them (verbs, adjectives, nouns that weren't proper and were in the middle of the sentence). I got him to try changing his story structure from a 'And Then' status to a more flowing narrative.
But it seems as though he's reached another plateau. He's making no improvements, even with gentle advice. I certainly don't want to give him a scathing review like the one that was left before, but I have difficulty even reading one of his stories in full. And yet, after every post he makes, he asks me what I think.
So I lie. I say 'it was interesting' or I mention any one sentence that stood out in my mind as being better than others of what I read. I try to encourage him to continue writing, because I hope to see improvement with time and he does have good ideas, just no knack for implementation of them. I really don't like lying, though.
I'm almost to the end of my rope with it, particularly after his most recent piece that was posted this morning. I need advice on how to handle it all, I think and that's why I'm asking people here.
Should I continue the lies? Should I be frank and truthful? Or should I suggest that he find another person to help him?
What would you do?
I have a friend that fancies himself a writer and he's earnest and sincere and tries really, really hard...but he's not very good at all. His grammar is atrocious, his spelling horrible and his sentence structure weak at best. He -tries- and you can tell that he's trying, but most of what he writes is on the same level as what you might expect from a fourth or fifth grader, despite his being of college age.
And, since I write, he comes to me regularly seeking praise.
I've attempted to work with him. I've had some progress. After somebody left a scathing review of one of his stories on DeviantArt that left him in tears, I managed to get some improvement from him by convincing him to stop capitalizing letters in places where there's no reason whatsoever to capitalize them (verbs, adjectives, nouns that weren't proper and were in the middle of the sentence). I got him to try changing his story structure from a 'And Then' status to a more flowing narrative.
But it seems as though he's reached another plateau. He's making no improvements, even with gentle advice. I certainly don't want to give him a scathing review like the one that was left before, but I have difficulty even reading one of his stories in full. And yet, after every post he makes, he asks me what I think.
So I lie. I say 'it was interesting' or I mention any one sentence that stood out in my mind as being better than others of what I read. I try to encourage him to continue writing, because I hope to see improvement with time and he does have good ideas, just no knack for implementation of them. I really don't like lying, though.
I'm almost to the end of my rope with it, particularly after his most recent piece that was posted this morning. I need advice on how to handle it all, I think and that's why I'm asking people here.
Should I continue the lies? Should I be frank and truthful? Or should I suggest that he find another person to help him?
What would you do?