Page 1 of 1
Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Sat Sep 24, 2011 7:41 pm
by CrystalKitten
I find myself wondering how you tell a guy (and his friends... and you're roommates... ) that he just.. doesn't seem to be your type? That's what I find myself wondering lately...
So, some of you guys may be familiar with the guy my roommate is trying to set me up with. She's leveled off a LITTLE bit on asking if we're talking... but still does sometimes. Then.. this weekend some of his/her friends are over here (not him though) and his friend is asking if I'm talking to him this weekend... And he even did something kind of strange and just went on and on about how he's a "good guy" without really saying WHY other than that he's known him for a while "He's a good guy. A really good guy. Lived down the street from him. Yeah, he's a good guy, went to school with him since grade 8" and other very vague stuff like that. So.. I feel like maybe they're trying to feel me out for my feelings towards him or something? It's hard to tell, cause I don't even know if the guy is interested... It's hard to tell cause he never talks about ANYTHING other than 1. games(but not even convo type things.. mostly.."wicked LoL game last night". 2. tv shows. 3 random links without seeming to have any desire to actually start a conversation/discussion about said links. The closest things to REAL conversations would probably be some of the tv discussions, but even those are pretty weak to the kinds of conversations I'm used to. There's just something about the "conversations" that seems.. so bland.. don't get me wrong.. I can go on for hours talking about absolutely nothing with the right people... JUst... not so much this guy.
So I mean.. I'm pretty sure he's not really the kind of person I'm looking for. Granted I haven't met in person yet, and maybe that could be a serious game changer.. but he lives 1-2 hours away and I don't have a car.. I don't even know if he does :/ (talked about this in the other thread I think). Still don't know what he looks like either (not ultimately important.. but matters a little.. especially if there's no insta-connection).
So, anyways. He's been talking to me more and more it seems (while still not saying anything, really), and now his friend is being all "Yeah, he's a good guy" and "yeah, I'll probably see him tomorrow"(not sure why that would matter to me.. maybe incase I.. wanted to send a message? I dunno.. that's what msn would be for <.<). So I'm not sure if he's interested, or just getting more comfortable with chatting as friends.
I'm definitely not interested... I need someone that can stimulate my mind, and hobbies... And when I was getting all excited trying to come up with possible genetic/biological explanations for the electric man video he linked me.. he kind of just.. played dumb and ignorant without even ANY sense of curiosity at ALL as to what might be behind it.. (or even in learning a bit about some of the concepts behind my theories..) And I'm the kind of person where I learn something cool, I like to try and apply it everywhere, and so that was kind of a downer

So, unless something drastic happens (like.. he's pretty damn cute, and decides to come down here and take me on an awesome date and OMG who knew he's actually pretty cool/interesting in person!) I really don't see anything ever coming of it.
Which leaves my dilemma:
From the sounds of things, could it be possible he IS even interested? Apparently he's "really shy", so.. I could kind of see that explaining the not being upfront about it, or wanting to come down when his friends do.. But.. he really is saying "what's up" a lot more, and now the whole thing with his friend trying to convince me he's "a good guy" heh.
What should I do/say about it? I obviously don't wanna just outright say "Yeah, I'm not really interested in you as more than a friend" as 1. I don't even know if that's what he's hoping for, and if it isn't, I'd feel REALLY awkward, and 2. I.. I have this thing where's it's REALLY hard to me to risk hurting people. Like.. I start crying just thinking about it.. even if it's something that doesn't actually matter all that much to them. And I don't want to just "leave it as it is, and deal with it if something more drastic does happen" because... not knowing.. and having it hanging over my head is getting kind of really annoying.. :/ I'm a bit odd. And sometimes guys tend to think I'm flirting or whatever online when I'm just being myself, so I really don't wanna risk leading him on without realizing it, or whatever. I've tried throwing out a FEW traps to get him to say SOMETHING that would reveal any intentions, but.. damnit.. the guy is more quiet than I am online.. I mean.. it's ONLINE... Shyness doesn't matter online <.< Worse case.. you say something stupid and then block the person, or delete your account out of embarassment!
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Sat Sep 24, 2011 8:50 pm
by Moore
IMO, if his friend is speaking on his behalf with the whole 'He's a good guy' thing then I would think the guy wants a relationship. Of all my time as a bro I have never brought up 'how awesome my friend is' unless they asked me too.
But yeah if you don't feel anything or whatever; there's nothing you can really do it's not like you're ending an actual relationship because there's not really one there. That's pretty much what dating is, like trying to find someone who matches if they don't then they don't and no one should feel bad about that, so long as they're respectful about it.
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Sat Sep 24, 2011 8:53 pm
by Anyia
Ah, the "joys" of the are-you-interested-I-might-be-interested game. I don't remember it fondly. A couple of... suggestions; I wouldn't call it advice as I never got any good at this, but:
When his friends are dropping hints about him being such a "good guy", you could always drag the conversation in the direction of "too bad he's not into biology, chem, outdoors, ..." (forgot your list of interests, sorry) as a counter-hint. If his friends have been sent to probe things, it'll get back to him near verbatim. If not, well, you haven't presumed anything. From your description, it does sound like he's interested (or thinks he's interested - female gamers tend to attract lots of male gamers regardless of personality *sigh*).
Also, I'll say this - it's a lot less painful to find out your target is already dating someone else than a plain "no thanks". Even if said date appeared after you started talking to the person.
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Sat Sep 24, 2011 9:10 pm
by CrystalKitten
Thanks guys, that helps a bit. I might go upstairs for a bit in a little while (I had... a horrible HORRIBLE day.. so I'm treating myself to a few drinks.. also cause i might need the help to tell them to go stfu if they're still banging around at bed time), maybe I can try dropping some hints...
See.. I wish I could just say "Yeah, sorry, but I met this other guy and blah blah blah" but.. The camp isn't going horribly well, only been a week though. Though... I DID mention the whole idea of "camping" to him.. but if anything, he's talking to me even more now (still no offer of a pic or something though.. and honestly... at this point that's probably he's best chance... not that I'm that superficial or anything).
And totally agreed on the comment about guys going after female gamers... I've had all sorts of... propositions... in game <.<
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2011 8:58 am
by CrystalKitten
Update:
First of all, I'm not sure that "the guy" knew his buddies were coming over.
Okay, so last I drank a few.. Had a REALLY bad freaking day, and I wanted chips.. but didn't have any.. so.. decided to have a few drinks. While I was on #3, I went upstairs to hang out a bit, and we got talking. They once again started saying what "a good guy" he was without giving any examples... :/ Then they gave me a few things to bring up to try and get him talking. I was like "Okay.. well.. let's see.." so I went down, grabbed my laptop, and tried to start prompting him. NOTHING. They start saying "hey" to him as well.. and all he says is "ahh, word", to which I look at the guys and just outright say "That's the extent of his vocabulary when we're chatting".
Meanwhile, they're still trying to upsell him.. Saying he's started working out with them, and trying to make him sound like a "bad boy", and all that. I tried to respond as blandly as possible.. "Yeah.. we'll see..." or stuff. Like.. they want to do stuff in Toronto when I got for my concert... But that's in 5 months... if things keep this way for that long, then I'll probably definitely not be interested then :/ I mean, it's only been a little while now.. and he's just.. boring. Can't start a conversation for anything.
I tried to feel him out so I knew what kind of thing might be necessary to say :/ And.. considering I was a little drunk (he even commented on it when I started typing backwards, haha) I figured... Okay.. let's say something COMPLETELY radical.. "So, I've come to the conclusion your friends must be trying to 'help you out'" (Replace 'help you out' with something a little more.. blunt <.<), which I figured should get SOME kind of reaction... "lol why" is not really the one I was expecting...
I just really hate leaving things hanging... I like to have things dealt with, and really don't want to end up having some awkward meetup the day of my concert or something :/ Really.. you'd think he show some kind of sign, but maybe I'm just oblivious to them since I'm not really all that interested :/
Oh, they tried to say he was a really smart guy cause he went to college for computer science.. But anything intellectual I try to talk about, he tends to brush off.. and even when I asked for COMPUTER ADVICE when my laptop had water spilled on it, or when I was thinking of getting my new one, he had NO input what-so-ever :/ If you can't even be confident in your field.. then what's the point of anything :/ Hell, most of my discussion on the electric man could have been total bullshit from stuff I mis-remembred, or just plain didn't know the details of, but at least I went with it, heh.
Yeah.. lots of walls of text on all these guy related things <.< Sorry. But it's kind of a big issue for me right now, hah.
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 6:19 am
by Morven
In my experience — if things are gonna work between me and someone (guy or girl), we'll have things to talk about. Lots to talk about. Five-hour-conversation lots to talk about. "Damn, how did it get so late?!" kinds of conversations.
If things don't go like that, I've found, a relationship will be a really, really bad idea.
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 8:15 am
by CrystalKitten
Morven wrote:In my experience — if things are gonna work between me and someone (guy or girl), we'll have things to talk about. Lots to talk about. Five-hour-conversation lots to talk about. "Damn, how did it get so late?!" kinds of conversations.
If things don't go like that, I've found, a relationship will be a really, really bad idea.
Yeah, that's what I've been thinking. The problem is, I don't know what to do about it. Or if he even is interested, or if his friends are just trying to "help him out". And I'm totally going with Anyia, in that any interest, or whatever, is based purely on the fact that I'm a female gamer. But yeah, as I said, not even sure if he IS interested.. I would have thought the comment about his friend trying to "help" would have gotten some reaction, but then.. this guy never says anything anyways. He's still talking to me quite a bit as well :/ It's amazing how often someone can talk to you without even saying anything :/
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 11:20 am
by Worba
1) Do what you feel. If he's a boring conversationalist, then start limiting / clipping your replies to him same as you would to any other person you found un-interesting. Just treat your interactions with him like he's just one more internet person. If he doesn't say anything to fire your imagination, don't respond. If he asks for a response, be polite but that's it. Honestly if all he's doing is communicating in grunts, this shouldn't be hard.
2) If he starts getting more talkative and dropping hints (beyond just frequent random links and "lulz" and "word"), THEN just ask him: are you coming on to me? If he says "yes" (or grunts to that effect), then say "I'm sorry, but I'm not interested". Sounds a bit cold but speaking as a guy, this simple non-openended statement may hurt at first but it will save both of you a lot of confusion and hurt later on.
3) Looks DO matter. It probably doesn't matter anyway in this case, so this is more of a general comment, but looks do matter and if you pretend otherwise, wait till you hook up and find yourself "window shopping" every time you leave the house. Not a big deal if you're just thinking about a quick fling but otherwise if you're looking for a relationship (and if he's 1-2 hours away, I'd think it would *need* to be a relationship to be worth the sacrifice). A mate doesn't have to be 10/10 ofc but looking at them should be at least SOME kind of a turn on. Maybe not when they first wake up (most humans don't), but at least once they've had their morning coffee and shower...
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 11:37 am
by CrystalKitten
Worba, lots of great advice
1. The problem is.. I talk a LOT online. Like.. a lot. It's like I build up anything I might ever want to say outloud, but can't cause of the anxiety, and as soon as someone says "what's up" then I'll either go off about what I'm doing, or whatever. Especially with some of the stuff I'm learning.. I find it REALLY cool.. I WANT to talk about it, but... don't have many other friends right now. One good example was when he posted the electric man link... That could tie in SO MUCH to some of the stuff I'm learning... I found it REALLY interesting to try and figure out some theories behind the inheritance patterns, or whatever <.< It would be like someone who doesn't give a crap about sports asking politely if some sports fanatic saw the _____ game last night...
2. He's definitely talking a bit more, but again, not saying much. I would definitely not think he was coming on to me :/ I mean.. maybe in some.. strange femiphobe (I made up a word, heh) kind of way.. but, I honestly can't tell.. I DEFINITELY would have expected something when he thought I was pretty drunk, but.. nada...
3. Pretty much exactly how I feel, yeah. Would have expected some sharing of photos. His buddies that were over tried to vid chat with him, and he wouldn't even do that with his buddies.
Maybe I'll just be blunt later today, and try and find out. Maybe a little less bluntly by saying something along the lines of "so.. what DO you think about our friends trying to set us up?"
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 12:08 pm
by Worba
CrystalKitten wrote:1. The problem is.. I talk a LOT online. Like.. a lot. It's like I build up anything I might ever want to say outloud, but can't cause of the anxiety, and as soon as someone says "what's up" then I'll either go off about what I'm doing, or whatever. Especially with some of the stuff I'm learning.. I find it REALLY cool.. I WANT to talk about it, but... don't have many other friends right now. One good example was when he posted the electric man link... That could tie in SO MUCH to some of the stuff I'm learning... I found it REALLY interesting to try and figure out some theories behind the inheritance patterns, or whatever <.<
The only question I can see here is A) is he intelligent but has learned (rightly or wrongly) to "dumb it down" when talking to girls so they don't think he's a nerd, or B) is this a simple case of WYSIWYG. If you suspect it's A then you could try just saying "I find this sort of thing very interesting - are you up on it or is this just not your cup of tea?"; if it's A, something like that will act as a "safety word" and he's going to open up if he has anything at all to say (and the guts to risk looking "smart"), otherwise it's probably B - and if he just isn't that bright (CS degree not withstanding), then my guess is you guys are NOT compatible. But ofc that's just a sense based on very limited info...
CrystalKitten wrote:2. He's definitely talking a bit more, but again, not saying much. I would definitely not think he was coming on to me :/ I mean.. maybe in some.. strange femiphobe (I made up a word, heh) kind of way.. but, I honestly can't tell.. I DEFINITELY would have expected something when he thought I was pretty drunk, but.. nada...
[...]
Maybe I'll just be blunt later today, and try and find out. Maybe a little less bluntly by saying something along the lines of "so.. what DO you think about our friends trying to set us up?"
Eh, he may just be the kind of guy who is a social clod but is used to being carried through by his buddies - from what you've told me his pal is definitely trying to set you up. Since his friend is the one doing all the talking, you might just ask HIM why he keeps talking about his pal e.g. "I've noticed that everytime we talk, you mention Bob - is there a reason for this?"

Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 12:17 pm
by CrystalKitten
Haha, well, when I was going all into the science and genetics possibilities behind the electric man, his response was almost exactly "I have no idea, I just think it's weird" ... So, I'm gonna guess he's not just that bright beyond computers, apparently (he still had no recommendations when I tried asking for advice about getting a new laptop :/ )
I'm socially awkward too. When they did keep talking about him though, I tried to just be all "Yeah... we'll see" or "Really? I couldn't tell". They also aren't here a lot. They, like him, don't live locally, so I don't really see them much (only twice). We'll see.. I'll try and figure something out and let you all know how it goes.
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 12:27 pm
by Worba
Good luck!
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 1:22 pm
by GormanGhaste
Maybe you're over-thinking all this. It's not your job to figure out if a guy is interested in you or not. If he is, he'll let you know. Otherwise, just treat him as a friend and don't worry about it.
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 1:28 pm
by CrystalKitten
Oh, I'm probably definitely overthinking it. The problem is my room mate and his friends (when they're over) don't drop it. And I have this thing where I HATE not knowing (It ties into my anxiety issues, it actually REALLY bothers me not knowing, even if it's something that doesn't matter). I tend to talk sometimes such that... I might send mixed signals unintentionally, just cause, that'swho I am (probably partially stems from my social ineptitude, and some other more serious issues that I won't go into).
So just waiting and see is... not exactly something I can do without putting stress on myself (and I really don't handle stress well either.
Re: Guy advice: How do you tell a guy...
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2011 4:11 am
by Anyia
Totally unrelated, but:
CrystalKitten wrote:definitely
My old GM would likely have a crush on you for spelling that correctly.
