Page 1 of 1
All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 12:23 am
by CrystalKitten
So, my sister just sent me a link to this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQHSVasbxU0
I'm wondering how long it'll be before there's a lawsuit. The flame war on that page is also amusing.
For those who don't know All Time Low (I'm a newer fan myself), they made this song:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4vbCraive8
It's pretty clear that the first is a complete rip off. The music/beat is the exact same only... crappier.. and the chorus is nearly identical as well. Apparently this other "band" is one of those Disney-style prefabbed for tv things.. I think done by Nickelodeon. Which makes me wonder how they thought they could get away with this. Some people are saying ATL must have given permission, but apparently just after the song was posted, their band manager tweeted pretty much a "wtf this isn't okay" response...
(Note, while I do have my opinions on Big Time Rush from the very minimal I've read about waht they are, that's not what this is about, incase there are any fans. This is about the fact that this one particular song is a direct rip-off)
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 12:27 am
by Lupis
I'm rofling at the comments on Big Time Rush's version. One person is clearly having an intense conversation with a troll.
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 2:07 am
by Bonita
I personally love btr and atl. I think this is a little funny though.
It's also kind of a bit sad they took lyrics. (Basically stealing the song....)
I know that Btr wrote most of their new album apparently so it makes me wonder if they personally stole it or if the producer did.
Reading the comments does make me happy that Im not a big crazy fan though. They all kinda look dumb to me O.o
And I do remember hearing this song a while ago but I thought it was just a cover by BTR. Didn't realize its not supposed to be I guess
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 2:41 am
by Gimlion
So BTR's isn't a cover? I was going to suggest that maybe it was... but huh.
This possibly is my favorite post on either video:
"i love big time rush so shut the fuck up!!(; they are amazing and can DEFINATELY sing. people are so stupid get your fuckin facts straight. dumbasses."
Where the hell does she ever post any proof of a fact in this statement? There's no fact even in it!
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 2:54 am
by Bonita
Lol I stopped reading the comments. Btr Fans cant seem to type and it was hurting my head. Im just going to wait and see what happens. Would be funny if it does up end saying its a cover once Btr's album is released.
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 8:02 am
by Lupis
I loved the comment "More like Big Time Lawsuit".
Don't read that one BTL fan's comments in a serious manner. He's a troll, and it's hilarious. He just says the same things over and over but adds in some swears.
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 9:22 am
by CrystalKitten
Haha, yeah, I definitely don't think it's a cover. People who do covers don't change the lyrics of the songs... Even if it went Weird Al style, they don't KEEP the half of the song pretty much exactly as is, and they get permission. For those who went looking for the manager's tweet like I did, it looks like he deleted it and replaced with a generic "Sometime the music industry sucks" or something. I'm going to guess their lawyer told them to make sure BTR couldn't counter with a slander suit.
As I said, I've never heard much at all about BTR... I... didn't even personally enjoy that "song" (or if you WANT to try and believe it's a cover.. their version). The overly synthed music just grates on my ears.. almost like that sound when someone is sharpening a knife... The fact that they would do something like that ensures they will never have my support even if they do become a "real" band.
I also didn't realize this was gonna be on an album. Thought maybe it was just a one shot, producers pulling it out, or something. I honestly didn't know much about Big Time Rush until now, so I'm reading up on them. The following quote from wikipedia makes me thing this WAS infact "stole". "... the show, which will incorporate original music" If they don't have a history of doing covers, then I think it's reasonable to assume this wasn't an attempt at a cover. And if they're going to try and make money off it by selling it on an album.. HUGE nono..
Haha, some of the ATL song "rewrites" about the theft are pretty good. The "I feel like stealing (dancing) tonight" one in particular.
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 1:46 pm
by cowmuflage
Haha so it's like most rap songs then? Alot of times they don't ask when they use a song in theres (and butcher the song too I might add).
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 5:51 pm
by Bonita
I actually went and listened to the Btr song last night. Deff not a cover.
It's a little sad.
I also didn't realize the songs going to be on their album either. Just wow. Ugh.
I started listening to BTR because it was one of the few things the girls I baby sit listen too thats not some bad rap songs about sex and drugs. (Their parents are terrible terrible people *sigh*)
Re: All Time Low fans: Be prepared
Posted: Wed Nov 16, 2011 12:02 am
by Gimlion
cowmuflage wrote:Haha so it's like most rap songs then? Alot of times they don't ask when they use a song in theres (and butcher the song too I might add).
Meh, I actually enjoy Samplings for certain rap songs. Some aren't so great, but songs like Sing for the Moment and No Love by Eminem are great songs IMO.