Page 1 of 2

sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 10:47 pm
by Slickrock
So I've started to farm for mini-pets and such, and need a tanking pet for some of that. So I let loose Aotona, since he didn't quite fit with my new-found dwarvish soul, and got the armoured boar that I like so much.

But.

Sadly, many of the places I am farming these are 4-5 or more mobs, and well, the boar isn't holding them.

So, what's a hunter to do? Is it back to a bear or croc?

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 10:55 pm
by Vephriel
For multiple mobs then I'd say yes, a Bear or a Crocolisk would probably be your best bet. I believe they're the only two tenacity pets with a racial ability that hits multiple targets.

Turtles have the best survivability though, in my opinion, so that could be a possible option as well.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 11:03 pm
by Ryai
The problem could also be you're not misdirecting threat onto the mobs. IE throw MD onto pet, sic pet on mob. Wait for Tstomp to be put off at first, then waste all 4 seconds with Volley, AotH up is optional but I usually always run with AotB up for the extra direct power to my pet since it's not a problem of DPSing the mobs down, but the pet staying on top of threat.

Vephriel wrote:For multiple mobs then I'd say yes, a Bear or a Crocolisk would probably be your best bet. I believe they're the only two tenacity pets with a racial ability that hits multiple targets.

Turtles have the best survivability though, in my opinion, so that could be a possible option as well.
And yeah for mass groups it really is these three pets. Bears have the best hands down, they need little micromanagement for their skills. Crocolisks are a bit tricky but doable. But they shine the best on a BM hunter with longevity tho for their Bad Attitude ability. Turtles, as Veph said are the best survivability pets due to the fact you can basically have Cower and Shell Shield on one pet. Then ontop of this, if BM, the cooldowns are nearly halved, meaning you get a 'bubble' once every 30 seconds.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 11:05 pm
by Gimlion
While those three are best for large groups, I can solo the groups of 6-12 Mammoths plus Jormungar next to Dun Nifflem for the Leathers with just my Worm and I. =) Also, Agreed with the MD thing.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 11:17 pm
by Ryai
Gimlion wrote:While those three are best for large groups, I can solo the groups of 6-12 Mammoths plus Jormungar next to Dun Nifflem for the Leathers with just my Worm and I. =) Also, Agreed with the MD thing.
Well I can too but it is best to start people off with the easy pets first before advancing to things such as worms and boars etc.

Remember baby steps are the best way for learning how to pet tank :d

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 11:20 pm
by Gimlion
Bah, Baby steps are for BABIES!!!!!!! :lol: No, but in all seriousness I understand. And at least we don't have to use Gorilladins anymore... There was one skin I liked, and He was always dead and laying there whenever i searched the cave (Uhk'Loc)...

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 11:23 pm
by Slickrock
Ryai wrote:
Gimlion wrote:While those three are best for large groups, I can solo the groups of 6-12 Mammoths plus Jormungar next to Dun Nifflem for the Leathers with just my Worm and I. =) Also, Agreed with the MD thing.
Well I can too but it is best to start people off with the easy pets first before advancing to things such as worms and boars etc.

Remember baby steps are the best way for learning how to pet tank :d
Oww... :?

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 11:26 pm
by Slickrock
Gimlion wrote:Bah, Baby steps are for BABIES!!!!!!! :lol: No, but in all seriousness I understand. And at least we don't have to use Gorilladins anymore... There was one skin I liked, and He was always dead and laying there whenever i searched the cave (Uhk'Loc)...
Yeah, I used to do it with Gorilladins, (and even have the BRK t-shirt to prove it!).

Yep, the MD-volley should work most of the time, but having something that generates AOE aggro by itself is always a plus. The AOE-fest that Wrath-raiding has the pet tanking a bit rusty.. :D

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 12:04 am
by Slickrock
Gimlion wrote:While those three are best for large groups, I can solo the groups of 6-12 Mammoths plus Jormungar next to Dun Nifflem for the Leathers with just my Worm and I. =) Also, Agreed with the MD thing.
BTW, just were are those groups?.. I was flying around, didn't see them. There's that temple area north of there with the rhinos and solo mammoths, but I don't see mammoths and worms together close to there...

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:10 am
by Allua
I got myself a turtle and never regretted it. Together we soloed MC (full), old style Ony, ZG (save for Jin'do), 4\6 AQ20, some Kara and all the lower level 5-mens up to Nexus and Utgarde Keep. I never liked turtles before this whole idea of soloing came to my mind, but now I'm a huge fan of them. Their Shell Shield is simply amazing, and even though the new version of Cower works much the same, TWO shield walls for a tank is better that one ;)

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:23 am
by FuzzyDolly
What I about a Carrion Bird? I believe Demoralizing Screech is an AoE. You could go get yourself one of those beautiful blue condors from Dragonblight.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:54 am
by Acherontia
Carrion Birds are Ferocity, but I have one, and she is just as good a tank as my bear was.

MD + Volley, AotB if you're having trouble, hitting Cower if the pet takes a lot of damage. Keep the pet on Defensive, as I believe they do hidden addition threat while set to this stance. Generally while doing the quests in Icecrown involving killing 10 of those Undead mobs (Converted Heroes), I do the whole lot at once without trouble. Two volleys kills them, and MD up on the first volley + whatever AoE the pet has works. AoE threat pets, in addition to all the Thunderstompies:

* Wolf (Furious Howl does some AoE threat simply by buffing you & pet, not much)
* Carrion Bird
* Tallstriders

* Sporebat
* Bear
* Crocolisk


The abilities of Tallstriders and Carrion Birds should also serve to make them take less damage. Using a Ferocity pet can also make fights go a lot faster, so if the pet isn't actually dying during the fight, you may want to consider trying one out.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 8:04 am
by Ryai
Acherontia wrote:Carrion Birds are Ferocity, but I have one, and she is just as good a tank as my bear was.

MD + Volley, AotB if you're having trouble, hitting Cower if the pet takes a lot of damage. Keep the pet on Defensive, as I believe they do hidden addition threat while set to this stance. Generally while doing the quests in Icecrown involving killing 10 of those Undead mobs (Converted Heroes), I do the whole lot at once without trouble. Two volleys kills them, and MD up on the first volley + whatever AoE the pet has works. AoE threat pets, in addition to all the Thunderstompies:

* Wolf (Furious Howl does some AoE threat simply by buffing you & pet, not much)
* Carrion Bird
* Tallstriders

* Sporebat
* Bear
* Crocolisk


The abilities of Tallstriders and Carrion Birds should also serve to make them take less damage. Using a Ferocity pet can also make fights go a lot faster, so if the pet isn't actually dying during the fight, you may want to consider trying one out.
No offense but Sporebats are to fragile imo to make decent tanking pets for serious things, as while they can do 'AoE' and be MD'd onto, they have no inbattle health regen family skills that Ferocity and Tenacity have, no lick your wounds, no growl = health back, no stamina buff like tenacity pets, etc etc.

And while Tallstrider's ability is alright, it's not good enough on it's own, Carrion bird is better because of the Screech, but again, people should really start off with a tried and true method of a tenacity pet until they get more into rhythm of throttling threat and MDing regularly onto a non tenacity pet.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 8:16 am
by Foru21dr
Curiosity is what talent build are you slick... As a marksman I find that most of my pets can not hold the aggro on a mob. Even my tenacity pets do not hold for very long. I have to use misdirect and feign death to get them back on. As a BM though, my aggro is much less and my pets can hold them longer. They most times can hold through the whole fight. So could part of your problem with the boar not holding the mob is that your spec pulls too much aggro?

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 8:39 am
by Acherontia
Very good point actually, spec should make a huge difference. As should the pet's spec. If your pet isn't dropping too much health, try speccing it wholly for DPS; the added damage output might help with threat generation.

And Ryai I wasn't suggesting a Sporebat as such, just listing the various AoE pets. I'm personally not a fan of the Cunning tree for anything bar PvP, and even then the damage seems too low for my style. I'll still break out the Chimaera in emergencies but having a Devilsaur solo a warlock in ~6 seconds is a great feeling. That said, I still find that there's a surprising lack of difference in the abilities of Ferocity and Tenacity pets in tanking, although the Thunderstomp ability certainly helps if you're unfamiliar.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 9:18 am
by Sarayana
I have a pet-attack+HM macro and I always, always, always put that up first. That way, my pet and I are attacking the same thing. Of course if I want to volley, MD is the way to go, like everyone else said.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 11:20 am
by Gimlion
Slickrock wrote:
Gimlion wrote:While those three are best for large groups, I can solo the groups of 6-12 Mammoths plus Jormungar next to Dun Nifflem for the Leathers with just my Worm and I. =) Also, Agreed with the MD thing.
BTW, just were are those groups?.. I was flying around, didn't see them. There's that temple area north of there with the rhinos and solo mammoths, but I don't see mammoths and worms together close to there...
It's the Area between Dun Nifflem and the Big Blue B****es place... There are two groups/herds of Mammoths (about 6 in each) that run in circles, and then there are the Jormungars in there for the Disembodied daily, and non-pack mammoths as well.

And IDK, I kinda like Cunning Pets... My Spider (Bone Spider) is prolly one of my favorites. But I love most of them. Windserpents, regular Serpents(Which was my first true main pet until Wrath, when i released him for a Devilsaur...) Chimaeras, Sporebats... actually Just about all of them except Bats and Ravagers are very neat IMO. And my Spider does enough Damage to suffice, and seems to withstand mobs better than my Cat... but idk if it's just me... I don't like most of the Cookie-Cutter Builds for Pets... The only one that is Cookie Cutter is my Wolf.
So it might be the way I specced them.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 12:10 pm
by Foru21dr
Gimlion wrote:
Slickrock wrote:
Gimlion wrote:While those three are best for large groups, I can solo the groups of 6-12 Mammoths plus Jormungar next to Dun Nifflem for the Leathers with just my Worm and I. =) Also, Agreed with the MD thing.
BTW, just were are those groups?.. I was flying around, didn't see them. There's that temple area north of there with the rhinos and solo mammoths, but I don't see mammoths and worms together close to there...
It's the Area between Dun Nifflem and the Big Blue B****es place... There are two groups/herds of Mammoths (about 6 in each) that run in circles, and then there are the Jormungars in there for the Disembodied daily, and non-pack mammoths as well.

And IDK, I kinda like Cunning Pets... My Spider (Bone Spider) is prolly one of my favorites. But I love most of them. Windserpents, regular Serpents(Which was my first true main pet until Wrath, when i released him for a Devilsaur...) Chimaeras, Sporebats... actually Just about all of them except Bats and Ravagers are very neat IMO. And my Spider does enough Damage to suffice, and seems to withstand mobs better than my Cat... but idk if it's just me... I don't like most of the Cookie-Cutter Builds for Pets... The only one that is Cookie Cutter is my Wolf.
So it might be the way I specced them.
From this statemnent, you are specced BM.. I found I can also have any of my pets handle 3 - 6 mobs as long as I'm BM and not pull them off of my pet. (I'm a level 80 and take on mobs level of 75 - 80). But if I switch to MM, I aggro them off within 3 shots. I can get a few more shots in if I use aTenacity pet, but I still draw them off. If I stay as a MM, I usually do not group more than 3 mobs so that I can kill them fairly quickly. But if I'm farming, and want to get several at one time, I go BM and use what pet I feel like using as they all seem to do fine. If I'm going up against an Elite that will take and give some damage, then I stay BM, buff up myself and my pet, and get out my tenacity pet that is specced to take damage.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 12:23 pm
by Gimlion
I could do the same with my croc in my MM spec, but I liked my Worm better. For large groups as a MM, it's best to have Barrage and Imp. Barrage, which I have both of on my MM spec. So maybe you're not using those talents? But W/ MM, I go Multi, MD, Volley, and watch the 3k crits go flying from it. But It definitely would be harder without those talents.

Re: sigh... which tanking pet...

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 11:02 pm
by Slickrock
I'm BM.

The place where I was seeing the issue the other day was in ZG. I was farming the raptors around the raptor boss, and the boar wasn't holding them, even with the first MD. Perhaps part of it is that my volley is hitting hard. 2 or 3 would always peel off to me. Maybe I need to volley in Viper.. :D

I'll have to watch the pet's focus to see if it's keeping enough to still be doing thunderstomp. That could be part of it too.

I haven't been using AotB, so I might try that as well.

So the screech from the carrion birds generates threat? Is it cone-based like the bear, or full radius like a croc?