Page 1 of 2
away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:45 pm
by tramani
i dont know about you but i am getting sick about those wolves in raids
yesterday i was in icc 10 with Aotona , I was doing ok dps , then the MT whisped me "hey wtf are you doing , wheres your raidpet???"
i replied that Aotona was my raidpet , then he gave me a speech about how wolves are the best and if you dont use wolves your a total noob
i was pretty pissed but i needed the frosties so i called bjomolf (my wolf)
i only have my wolf for idiot raidleaders , else i wouldv used that stable for gondria
im so getting sick of all those wolves
If you like wolves , be my guest to use your buddy in raids , if you dont like wolves (like me) then you should be able to use another pet you do like
do you think the same about this? is blizz making plans about this?
post below if you agree/disagree and give some opinions

Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:53 pm
by Acherontia
I personally don't care what someone's using as long as it it's ferocity. If you're losing 200 dps out of 7k in a pug raid, who cares? If you're still doing 6.8k dps with a bird, I don't see the problem.
On the other hand, I would only bring a very top dps pet to a guild's progression raid. Yeah that pet can vary, but I won't go bringing a spirit beast. Devil or wolf, or bird if I'm bored on bosses we've already done.
The 'total noob' comment is a bit over the top, though; you are aware that wolves are top dps, but they aren't your choice of pet. And that is your choice.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:56 pm
by Redith
I think they should put the wolves howl as a ferce pets tallent tree, and think wolves new tallent should be "Hold" -Target cannot move or attack for 3 seconds. I got the idea for hold after watching Military K9s do their job lol
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:58 pm
by Aleu
The wolf gives a nice little buff, but I never see it as required. Now granted if I'm doing progression raiding, then yes. I would bring my puppy. However, if we're just downing bosses we always do, I may bring my kitty or go BM for kicks.
So for progression? I would go ahead and use the wolf for the buff. For other stuff? Use what you want.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:58 pm
by Gimlion
Even In progression, as a MM/SV you can get away with most Ferocity pets, if not all, and about the same as BM, but a few shine more than others, those being the Wolf, DS, and raptor. And SB's aren't that far behind a wolf. If I remember correctly, last time I plugged into FemaleDwarf, I got a higher DPS with a SB than with a wolf. It's all a matter of how you spec/use them.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:59 pm
by Kryte
While I agree it would be nice to be able to bring any pet you like to do whatever, for that to be possible, all pets would have to be the same (and, even then, you would have people complaining about certain pets. Big pets that block people's views, for example, are irksome to a lot of people, including myself). Otherwise, you simply end up with a situation where you have a new "best" pet, even if the difference is only marginal. I'd personally rather have a situation where there's a "best" pet than have one where pets all have the same abilities.
My best suggestion is to avoid pugging things and do content with people you like and are easy-going.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 3:03 pm
by Tahlian
But you see, that's the problem. For all that they've given us exotic pets and cunning pets and tenacity pets and ferocity pets of every possible species and color of the rainbow..."conventional wisdom" says you must use a wolf. Weren't we supposed to have a choice in what pet we bring?
Blizz has said they're not happy with the fact that the "wolf or GTFO" culture has sprung up, but they're apparently waiting till Cataclysm to actually address it. Very likely that's because it'll require making changes to both the wolf family and the Ferocity talent tree, and that's a bit much to ask when coping with a major content patch and expansion testing at the same time.
Please note - nowhere have I said I want it to go back to the bad old days where wolves sucked. I'd just like for everyone to feel they have a greater choice in what they bring, and for that freedom of choice to be respected by raid leaders.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 3:05 pm
by Anansi
It always bothers me when non-Hunters try to tell me how to play my class and it makes me get extremely sarcastic and snarky with them. Usually at that point my wife is telling me "take a deep breath" :p
It is true that a Wolf will give you the biggest DPS boost right now, however that is not to say other Ferocity pets are "total noob" options. If you brought a Tenacity or Cunning pet as your general purpose pet then yes, some depricating commentary would not be out of place, but as long as you've at least got a Ferocity pet with you, you're fine.
As for Blizzard doing something about it, they might be. Pets are being changed in Cataclysm to provide raid buffs and debuffs more than Hunter DPS. That said, there is bound to be that one pet that is widely considered best for raiding. That has always been true, and I don't see that ever changing.
They haven't changed it yet because Blizzard have been generally quite happy with where Hunters are at DPS-wise, and nerfing Wolves would be a class nerf for most raiders, so there would need to be changes made elsewhere that really wouldn't make sense to do this close to the expansion.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 3:11 pm
by Acherontia
http://forums.wow-europe.com/thread.htm ... 4856&sid=1
For anyone who is interested, I had posted two possible solutions to this.
The better one IMO was:
Allow each family to have its own skill which does NOT affect damage. The ones that currently don't can remain unchanged, the others changed.
For example:
Cats/spirit beasts: Prowl
Silithids/Spiders/Crabs: Root (no DoT)
Wolves: Howl to increase movement speed
Wasps: Angry Buzz--decreases nearby enemies' chance to hit
Ravagers/Bats: Stun
Carrion Birds: Demo Screech
Chimaera: Froststorm Breath--slows with no damage.
etc.
THEN allow ANY pet to ALSO train a Damage-affecting ability, i.e. mangle, furious howl, monstrous bite, faerie fire or sunder debuff.
In other words, all families would be unique BUT EQUAL in PvE. For PvP you can simply pick the pet you prefer for family skill + a damaging ability, and thus none would be OP, as various pets are situationally useful.
I really hope someone at Blizz reads this and considers it, because I think it would truly allow hunters to choose the pet they are -drawn to- rather than the one they feel boxed into using.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 3:14 pm
by Rhyela
I think that would work. I don't want pets to lose their unique family feel, but am of increasing belief that those unique skills really shouldn't affect damage. Make it the hunter's choice to spec the pet of their choosing how they want, with the fun little utility skill as an added bonus. That'd go a long way in equalizing things without watering it all down so much, because even the whole buff/debuff thing they've mentioned feels a bit iffy to me. We may still find ourselves being forced to use x pet for y debuff, which I don't like.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 6:13 pm
by Gimlion
Honestly, And it may be the server I am have been on since I started, but I have never felt the pressure to use a 'MUST HAVE OR GTFO' pet except from my guilds former Hunter CL, who while being a nice guy/friends, was much too obsessed with raiding, and thus moved to a dif. guild on hordeside. I have seen the numbers... ANY Ferocity pet is within reasonable and non raid-breaking differences, that it shouldn't matter which you bring. And, there appear to be a few Cunning pets that do a fair amount of DPS with their abilities, that while lower than Ferocity, still won't gimp a raid. So while sure, Devilsaurs and Wolves are the best pets you can bring, bringing something else for a little bit of flavor, or even to fill a debuff, as long as it's within reason (Ferocity, and a few Cunning) won't ruin a raid.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 10:39 pm
by Slickrock
I'm going to look at this from a progression raiding situation. If you are doing heroics or something else, pick whatever pet you want.
First off, if you are MM or SV, your best bet is bringing a wolf, or a wasp if you don't have a moonkin for that debuff. No way around it, the wolf will be ~50dps or more than any other pet, other that then wasp, if that debuff is missing.
Not much more to say there. It's the way Blizz has made the game for now.
BM is a totally different picture. First off, the wolf buffs you less. That's what most uninformed raid leaders and such don't realize. With MM, you are pushing YOUR AP, so the wolf's howl is that much more powerful. With BM not as much.
Since my server is down today, I'm going to run the numbers for my gear (about 6050 gearscore, and about 650 passive ArP) and FULL raidbuffs. The raidbuffs are the key, if you don't have full buffs, then it's really hard to compare. So let's assume my raid gear and full raid buffs.
The following are the combined hunter and pet dps (as calculated on femaledwarf):
Devilsaur: 10409.88
Raptor: 10391.21 (-18.67)
Wolf: 10371.06 (-38.82)
Wasp: 10162.27 (-247.61)
Spirit Beast: 10215.39 (-194.49)
Corehound: 10203.21 (-206.67)
Cat: 10143.83 (-266.05)
Moth: 10122.15 (-287.73)
Carrion Bird: 10107.53 (-302.35)
Tallstrider: 10064.39 (-345.49)
Worm: 9465.06 (-944.82)
What's going on here? It's simple, some of the pets don't scale well with the raid buffs.
Again, these are with FULL raid buffs (and debuffs) with my gear, gemming for ArP (I'm also dropping arcane out of the rotation due to the ArP). Worm and wasp don't help you since those debuffs are already being provided.
Now, let's look at it with NO raid buffs (or debuffs).
Devilsaur: 5443.87
Raptor: 5423.44 (-20.43)
Wolf: 5497.60 (+53.73)
Spirit Beast: 5384.25 (-59.62)
Wasp: 5454.59 (+10.72)
Corehound: 5392.71 (-51.16)
Cat: 5337.36 (-106.51)
Worm: 5531.47 (+87.6)
So surprise, in my gear, gemmed for ArP, the Worm is actually the best solo dps pet!! And without the raid buffs, the trex does fall behind the wolf.
Another surprise, that the raptor is a perfectly viable raid pet when you start gemming for ArP (I don't remember them being that close before). The raptor is also better in fights where it is switching targets a lot, which hurts the trex's monstorus bite which needs to stack for full effect.
Something to note here... If you are gemming straight agility, these rankings might very well be different for you. Also, at lower gear levels, the differences will be closer, so there will be less reason to always pick the "top" pet.
So what does this all mean?
If you are not raiding, just about any pet is viable, and there are some surprises in what some can do.
If you are raiding, you should do some math and see what pets work for you, but there are choices (unless you are MM).
If you are progression raiding (ICC25 or ICC10HM), bring your best dps pet (one of those top 3 likely). Not doing so is like refusing to use a flask. It's not fair to the rest of the raid.
And let me be clear, I'm not meaning this as a knock on anyone. I want people to be informed (and check the numbers themselves) for what dps pets actually do. If you love your sporebat, that's awesome! Just don't bring it to ICC25.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 10:47 pm
by Gimlion
Well, Slick, this is where I disagree... I consider anything within around 300 or so from best to still be a viable pet, while you consider anything within 50 viable. If you're in a group, unless it's progression, 300 dps should not make or break the raid, and if everyone honestly thinks that it's your fault for something like that, then they're prolly not worth the effort. 300 DPS in just about anything nowadays WILL NOT and IS NOT going to make or break the raid, with the exception of possible progression bosses. So looking at the numbers then, Really, it's just the Strider in the Ferocity tree that wouldn't be 'up to par' and even then, it's still relatively close for me.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 11:18 pm
by Slickrock
Well Gim, I'd have to respectfully disagree there. Let's put it this way, a flask plus food is worth about 100dps or so. If you draw the line at 300dps, then really, flasking or eating shouldn't be mandatory either. I think a 300 dps differential is too wide, at least for ICC progression raiding.
If it's farm content, or heroics, that's another story.
Also though, if you are pugging the raid, bringing a tallstrider is not the way to make a good impression, farm content or not.
Something else that hasn't been stated that should be. The dps calculations don't factor in other utility that various pets bring. Disarm, AP-reduction, lengthened cast times, etc, all can benefit the raid, but don't show in the dps meters. A good RL should know that, and even request different ones, but most don't.
EDIT: Actually, I think we are agreeing. Progression is the key. But I would expand it to when you need to make a good impression.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 11:20 pm
by Nick
Honestly, if anyone in a raid whispers me to bring out my wolf I use for raids, I would reply with "And where do you expect me to tame a wolf at the moment?"
They'd probably get pissy at me for not having a wolf in my stables because I'm full with spots atm. cx
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 11:24 pm
by Slickrock
Harpier wrote:Honestly, if anyone in a raid whispers me to bring out my wolf I use for raids, I would reply with "And where do you expect me to tame a wolf at the moment?"
They'd probably get pissy at me for not having a wolf in my stables because I'm full with spots atm. cx
And really, there's no reason you have to have one either.
I've found now that I don't get any arguments about bringing my Trex, even in pug raids.
Once Cata is here and we have more slots, I'll have a worm to bring out when there's not a warrior around. That dps increase is nice, and it applies to others in the group too.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 5:50 am
by FuzzyDolly
I am so tired of this whole "must have wolf" thing. How many threads do we have going on this? Umpteen billion? It's not that I hate wolves, actually I like them and would love to use Ironjaw or Timber. However, what I hate is the feeling of wolves being the mandatory and only pet to be used. I really wish Blizz makes changes to pets in Cat. I feel pets should have talent tree choices like toons. That way ANY pet could spec cunning, tenacity, or ferocity. Make the special pet attacks a talent to be specced into. Then we could have a moth, or an owl, or anything with furious how, or demoralizing screech, or whatever. Yes, some names would have to be changed, a bear with web would be silly, but just call it a stun and give it a different animation for each pet. Then people would have to find something else to hate BM hunters about and we wouldn't have to stare at 10 of the same worgs in a 25 man raid.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 9:13 am
by gaghiel
Having never really made it to higher levels yet (although I'm getting there, just broke 50 yesterday), I haven't had the amount of experience you guys have with raids and stuff, but I share the sentiment. While researching 'what is the best pet' and such I definitely picked up on the "Wolf is the best" vibe and was sad.
I've kinda always had a "hunters should stay out of raids" feeling and even avoid the random dungeons for fear of getting yelled at for having some sort of newb pet or for not keeping him on a short enough leash. I'm used to tanking/soloing so I pretty much go Tenacity but once I hit 60, I'll get my T-rex and Core Hound and be good to go. Im really hoping for some major changes in favorite pet types once Cat hits.
Re: away with wolves
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 10:05 am
by Slickrock
gaghiel wrote:Having never really made it to higher levels yet (although I'm getting there, just broke 50 yesterday), I haven't had the amount of experience you guys have with raids and stuff, but I share the sentiment. While researching 'what is the best pet' and such I definitely picked up on the "Wolf is the best" vibe and was sad.
I've kinda always had a "hunters should stay out of raids" feeling and even avoid the random dungeons for fear of getting yelled at for having some sort of newb pet or for not keeping him on a short enough leash. I'm used to tanking/soloing so I pretty much go Tenacity but once I hit 60, I'll get my T-rex and Core Hound and be good to go. Im really hoping for some major changes in favorite pet types once Cat hits.
Well, back in the BRK glory days, hunters were almost required for raids...
But there's no reason to be afraid of going in instances, or raids. And until you get to 80 and high gear levels, the whole wolf issue isn't an issue. Bring a ferocity pet to groups and you are fine. You really should start doing some groups just to learn the ways of CC in a group.
However, there's nothing wrong with soloing either..

Re: away with wolves
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 10:11 am
by Slickrock
FuzzyDolly wrote:Make the special pet attacks a talent to be specced into. Then we could have a moth, or an owl, or anything with furious how, or demoralizing screech, or whatever. Yes, some names would have to be changed, a bear with web would be silly, but just call it a stun and give it a different animation for each pet. Then people would have to find something else to hate BM hunters about and we wouldn't have to stare at 10 of the same worgs in a 25 man raid.
Agreed.
Ideally what I would like to see is something like what Acherontia posted.
1) Give each pet family a non-dps special ability (prowl, snare, dust, etc.)
2) Make all the dps talents trainable via talent points.
That would give us variety, choices, and better scaling as we progress through the expansion.