Page 1 of 3

Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Thu Jun 17, 2010 10:10 pm
by Rottingham
I love the TV show Deadliest Warrior! So, I figure I'd have a Deadliest Pet challenge for a little while!

Here's how it works, I'll put up a poll. In two nights, I will take the two pets with the most votes and put up the pros and cons of them. After careful annalysis 9and with the help of some judges...) I shall make a decision of who would be...

THE DEADLIEST PET

Also, first three people to pm me will be the three judges for the first fight first three for the second fight will be the judges for that fight, and on and on...

Well, use the poll and HAVE FUN :D

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Thu Jun 17, 2010 10:13 pm
by Pawtrack
Nice idea! This should be cool. :D

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Thu Jun 17, 2010 11:42 pm
by Rottingham
wow, a few more votes then i thought there would be at this time lol

I'm going to be gone all day tomorrow, that is why I'm gunna have the poll go for two days :P I just thought it would be an interesting thing to do :P

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Thu Jun 17, 2010 11:55 pm
by Victorelle
I think the cat would win... just my guess :3

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 12:40 am
by Tahlian
I think this would come down to a tie between the panther and the serpent, with a slight edge to the Panther as a Ferocity pet. The Wind Serpent lightning breath is nice, but it's a one-shot damage ability, and the Wind Serpent is a cunning pet. Mazzranache's Dust Cloud would give him early survivability...but holy cripes that special has a long cooldown. The Northrend Worg's Furious Howl is straight attack power...but where that becomes a powerhouse is how well it scales with raid buffs on both pet and hunter, so it's no real advantage in a fight like this. The Hyena's Tendon Rip is a mobility debuff, and for pet versus pet combat, that's not going to make that much of a difference, as pets don't kite. The Panther and the Serpent both have a DoT attack, so they're fairly evenly matched, with a slight advantage, as I said, to the Panther for its Ferocity family classification.

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 4:06 am
by Redith
hey Im making a Deadliest warrior thing too, cept its hunter vrs rogue. Anywho are you making this a macinama? If so I would volenteer to be one of the "Experts" for one of the animals

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 4:36 am
by Saturo
The windserpent would defibrillate it's enemies to death long before they could reach it. It's obvious that the windserpent would win.

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:21 am
by Rottingham
Redith wrote:hey Im making a Deadliest warrior thing too, cept its hunter vrs rogue. Anywho are you making this a macinama? If so I would volenteer to be one of the "Experts" for one of the animals
no sorry, no maciname... I have no idea how to do those things :P sorry. It's just gunna be written down...
Tahlian wrote:I think this would come down to a tie between the panther and the serpent, with a slight edge to the Panther as a Ferocity pet. The Wind Serpent lightning breath is nice, but it's a one-shot damage ability, and the Wind Serpent is a cunning pet. Mazzranache's Dust Cloud would give him early survivability...but holy cripes that special has a long cooldown. The Northrend Worg's Furious Howl is straight attack power...but where that becomes a powerhouse is how well it scales with raid buffs on both pet and hunter, so it's no real advantage in a fight like this. The Hyena's Tendon Rip is a mobility debuff, and for pet versus pet combat, that's not going to make that much of a difference, as pets don't kite. The Panther and the Serpent both have a DoT attack, so they're fairly evenly matched, with a slight advantage, as I said, to the Panther for its Ferocity family classification.
Well, I'm going by real life senerioa, not just how it would play out in wow... So their special abilities are nice, but the toughness of their skin, power of their jaws,a nd shedding of their claws all play factors, too

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:26 am
by Saturo
In that case, the windserpent would drop down onto the enemy, breathing lightning. It would twirl around the enemy, and bite it.

A swift death for the enemy, eh?

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:43 am
by Teigan
Mazz has deadly, deadly poison when wild, remember? :D

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 11:05 am
by Bulletdance
This is a really fun idea. :lol: When I read the title tho all I could think of was "deadliest catch" and picturing hunter pets crab fishing on the barren sea is hilarious.

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 12:33 pm
by Arkiss
Wind serpent I think edges out over the competition simply because it can attack at a range. Mazz's poison requires it to get up close, at which point any self-respecting flying creature would just ascend out of reach. You can argue that the cat or Mazz would be able to leap high enough to strike at it, but that's not only a huge expenditure of energy, if they miss they risk what could be a serious fall.

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 4:48 pm
by Razzy
Anything that flies and can shoot bolts of electricity would win against something using claws or teeth. It's like a sniper.

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 7:05 pm
by Rottingham
I still have no judges! If there are no other judges, then I'll be the only one to decide who wins from the two winners who wins round 1...

Don't forget, you have to PM me to be a judge. First 3 to PM me are my judges.

Something else I should point out... Is there is a tie, meaning that two judges say one pet, and me and the other judge say the other pet, then the I want to know what you guys would want me to do... so you guys can help me decide my method. should I:
-Just have whoever I voted for win (I am the creator anyways)
-pm a person at random to find out who they think should win
-have it end in a draw, in which both pets die
-have it end in a draw, in which both pets live
-take my vote out, because I could possible be playing favoritism...
-have a devilsaur just come in and go all "OMNOMNOM" on the two of them (This is not a real option... I just wanted some comic relief :P)

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 7:08 pm
by Pawtrack
Bulletdance wrote:When I read the title tho all I could think of was "deadliest catch" and picturing hunter pets crab fishing on the barren sea is hilarious.
LOL QFT

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 7:21 pm
by Rottingham
Bulletdance wrote:This is a really fun idea. :lol: When I read the title tho all I could think of was "deadliest catch" and picturing hunter pets crab fishing on the barren sea is hilarious.
ROFL!!! I read all of the comments but must have missed this for some reason! I'm very sorry for not discovering it earlier!

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Sat Jun 19, 2010 9:20 am
by Rottingham
Sorry for the double post... but it looks like we have our contenders!

The Cunning Panther, and the Venomous Mazzanache!

Pro's for the panther:
-Stealth
-Sharpened Claws
-Rake
-Vicious Bite
-Speed

Con's for the panther:
-Not too well armored

Pro's for Mazzanache:
-Poisonous bite
-Dust Cloud kicking
-Razor Beak
-Thickened Feathers
-Extreme Leg Strength
-Talons

Con's for Mazzanache:
-Slow
-The opposite of stealthy (That pink is hard to miss...)

Now I still have no judges, and if there are none then I will run the simulation myself. And I will be the one wjo decides...

THE DEADLIEST PET!!!

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Sat Jun 19, 2010 9:26 am
by Redith
Rottingham wrote:Sorry for the double post... but it looks like we have our contenders!

The Cunning Panther, and the Venomous Mazzanache!

Pro's for the panther:
-Stealth
-Sharpened Claws
-Rake
-Vicious Bite
-Speed

Con's for the panther:
-Not too well armored

Pro's for Mazzanache:
-Poisonous bite
-Dust Cloud kicking
-Razor Beak
-Thickened Feathers
-Extreme Leg Strength
-Talons

Con's for Mazzanache:
-Slow
-The opposite of stealthy (That pink is hard to miss...)

Now I still have no judges, and if there are none then I will run the simulation myself. And I will be the one wjo decides...

THE DEADLIEST PET!!!
i will judge if u will let me. and with your permission....can I make a machinama after we are done?

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Sat Jun 19, 2010 9:29 am
by Rottingham
OF COURSE YOU CAN! I would love it! alright, PM me yours thoughts of who you think should win and why. I still need 2 more judges, so if not then Redith is the only judge and he will decide the fate of these two murderous beasts!

Re: Deadliest Pet!

Posted: Sat Jun 19, 2010 9:33 am
by Saturo
I could be judging as well, if ya want me to.

I won't make machinema about it tough. :D