BaldingBarry wrote:.....(used seperately or at the same time for those 'oh carp!' moments).....
Yeah, gotta watch those carp. Sly devils.
I actually have a few I didn't expect to love as much as I do:

Sheldon has gone through a couple color changes (first the red turtle, then gray, then green, then gray again), but he has always been my main dude for tanking. He's awesome, and he's so adorable. My guild knows him and asks how he's doing. Whenever I know I need a reliable tank for something, I call Sheldon to my side. He's one of the main reasons I probably won't get Terrorpene. Sheldon just wouldn't be Sheldon unless he was this one.

Napthali is just an altogether special pet. I saw the skin as a critter in ICC and thought it was pretty, and looked for a tamable version (always liked spiders, but had only ever tried tarantulas and couldn't get into them). I saw a few, one of them being Naraxis, a rare in Duskwood. I love rare pets, so that's the one I went after. However, it wasn't there when I arrived. So, I went to the next closest place which was in Zul'Gurub. There were mobs there called Razzashi Broodwidows. After some embarrassingly failtastic pulls that almost led to my untimely demise, I finally managed to tame one of these beauties. Named her Naphthali which is Hebrew for "struggling" (a perfect fit considering the circumstances). I thought I'd replace her with Naraxis if I ever found it. I looked one evening and there sat Naraxis. I placed Naphthali on "Stay" at the entrance to the cave so I could look at Naraxis. But when I turned my camera back to Naphthali, I just couldn't swap her out. She was special to me, even though she wasn't rare. Now, go figure, the Razzashi Broodwidows are gone while Naraxis remains. My girl is now more rare than a rare.

Mortimer was an impulse tame. I don't even like ghostly pets for the most part, but I was bored one day and figured I'd give him a shot. I ended up falling in love with his derpy personality. However, when 4.0 launched and I saw the green jormungar, I decided to change him. Ghostly Mortimer was hard to see (I don't play with nameplates on), and green is my favorite color, so it seemed an obviously good move. However.....I haven't used the new Mortimer. I dearly miss my old derpy friend. I intend to get him back soon. Maybe I should just do that now.....

While I knew I would love this model of scorpid when I got it, I wanted my future Vulkoor to be green. As stated somewhere above, green is my favorite color and with the T11 gear and such, he would match me and my crazy green hair perfectly. It was a match made in heaven! However, during what I was expecting to be a day-long camp, a black Madexx spawned behind me (my first Madexx, a bronze, spawned in front of me. A subsequent bronze Madexx tamed by someone else also spawned in front of me...but black spawned behind). My plan was to give him to a friend who wanted Madexx. I was pressing tame, then cancelling, hoping that someone seeing the tame icon would pass him by and not kill him, and that way I could hold him for a while. Couldn't find my friend, so I pulled up a /who list. Well, since I was distracted, I accidentally tamed this black Madexx. Annoyed that I failed to find an owner (and that he didn't spawn in green when I was the only one around to tame), I tossed him in the stable. Fast forward a couple days and another friend tamed a bronze Madexx. We were taking group pics, so I went to my stable and yanked out my black Madexx (who at this point I still didn't care for, I was intent on getting green). However, a funny thing happened. While we were there taking our pics, this black Madexx began to take on this feeling that he was
mine. It's really rather difficult to explain. Nes had her green, Bloodd had his bronze (though he's still hoping for blue), up to that point I still didn't have one I liked.....but this black one started to really grow on me. He spawned for
me. His was the only time that no one else was around when he spawned. He was the only one to spawn behind me. He was just special from the beginning. And, I do love his colors. It's just that he doesn't "match" my future gear, and I was letting that get in the way. Had it not been for Bloodd getting bronze Madexx, I might have never gotten the chance to give my black one a chance. I could have missed one of my favorite pets because I was obsessed with having a matching pet. Thank goodness Bloodd got his when he did. Now there's no way I could even think of replacing him with green, he's my little emo dude and I adore him.