I was kind of the same way with Karoma. At first I was like, ok, it's pretty, I'll tame it if I find it. Then a shammy friend helped me tame it, and we instantly clicked. Whisp is now tied with Loq and Sabre for Kel's favorite pet.
I like how the kitty matches, but then I'm also just partial to cats. >.> (and you can turn prowl off, just right-click the icon) A fox might be a good idea to try, though.
Also, my baby tauren on Nesingwary, Shadepaw, is a scribe, but she's not high enough to make the rename scrolls (yet).
Kelesaria's shale spider tanked the Crucible in Twilight Highlands. For non-BM, though, her recently-tamed fire turtle, Charcoal, has been the best tank I've ever had. Shell shield is total win, and he holds aggro even over her 30k+ crits. The (very) few times Kel does pull aggro, a quick Kill Comma...
Kel's pride watcher Sabre likes to nuzzle/rub his face on her hand or leg, and roll onto his back, looking at her adoringly. Funny thing is, he does those emotes more often when I am having a bad day IRL. It always gives me major *warm fuzzies*. <3
How about.... a tallstrider that looks like the Ravenlord mount? :shock: It could be either level 20-something in the Barrens, or 80+ in Hyjal. I'm pretty horrible at coming up with good names though, so I have no idea what it could be called. Another option would be a white or black version of Samb...
My Kelesaria finally got him a couple weeks ago, after looking for what seemed like at least a month. She named him Rage, and loves him to death. So worth the camping frustration.
(Now if only Skoll would stop hiding from her....)
I think I agree with Kamoodle, you tag him you tame him. The other hunter shouldn't have broken your tame in the first place. I had something like that happen when I found Loque the first time. A BE hunter was at the spawn, but i tagged him first and started taming. He took aggro, I got it back, the...