Stupid roll system....

[Lisaara]

We 11-manned OS 3d 25. Me and this other hunter needed. We both got 85. It gave it to him! >/ Dude, you should have to reroll(the two that tied) if that happens. GRRRR!

[Novikova]

Yeah, that drives me nuts too. I've lost boe epics and at least one mount to it.

[Lotusii]

I have always hated that. It's just so irritating because it really seems sometimes like you're always on the losing end of a tie roll. I've lost like five or six mount rolls that way and I don't even know how it decides who gets the item when ties happen.

[Litlemouse]

...I don't even know how it decides who gets the item when ties happen.

Maybe the person who wants/needs it less?
Joking joking, but yeah it sucks

[Vephriel]

If rolls tie then a second, hidden roll is done behind to select one over the others.

[Lotusii]

You learn something new every day. I knew there was a method and that was the most likely, but it still stings.

[Lisaara]

If rolls tie then a second, hidden roll is done behind to select one over the others.

I was told it was just done alphabetically. I was on Jessibelle. The dude's name started with a H.

[MaximumOverdrive]

Everything I've read, it's always been that it does a second hidden roll if there's a tie.

[Saturo]

Aye, it's a second roll. He won it fairly.

[Lisaara]

Still sucks. He was one of those huntards too....he died in the wall of fire.....

[Comett]

lame

maybe next time?

[Lisaara]

lame

maybe next time?

Hope so. It's one of my favorite drakes. ;-;

[Worba]

It would be nice if the loot roll included a comment for ties, e.g.

Jessibelle rolled need - 85 (tiebreaker roll 51)

Huntard rolled need - 85 (tiebreaker roll 74)

Other person rolled need - 34

Etc.

That way everything's 100% out in the open.

[Lisaara]

It would be nice if the loot roll included a comment for ties, e.g.

Jessibelle rolled need - 85 (tiebreaker roll 51)

Huntard rolled need - 85 (tiebreaker roll 74)

Other person rolled need - 34

Etc.

That way everything's 100% out in the open.

Exactly!!!!

[Yaone]

Hmm on a different note, you needed 11 for 25 man? We got 10 man down with three, although it was pretty scary there at the end. (DK tank/dps, feral druid, rogue)