This is different from Kalli's list in that it only documents what's going into the Petopia database and covers boring new tameables (and untameables) as well as interesting ones.
Please let me know if anything's missing. If you test a beast as tameable, please actually try to tame it. It could be flagged but in practice give the "already controlled" message.
Thanks

Spirit Beasts

ID: 69943
Look: spectralporcupine
Level 90 Elite
Kun-Lai Summit
Must be reduced to 20% health before taming. Hits very hard, so kiting is probably necessary. Runs fast so Aspect of the Cheetah could be useful. Scatter Shot and Entangling Roots do NOT work.

ID: 69946
Look: spectralporcupinegreen
Level 90 Elite
Jade Forest
Must be reduced to 20% health before taming. Hits very hard, so kiting is probably necessary. Casts an interruptable heal while moving. Scatter Shot, Silencing Shot, and Entangling Roots work.

ID: 69947
Look: spectralporcupinered
Level 90 Elite
Krasarang Wilds
Must be reduced to 20% health before taming. Hits very hard, so kiting is probably necessary. Can be deadly if you are too far or too close, so needs to be kited at just the right distance. Scatter Shot and Entangling Roots do NOT work.
Devilsaurs

ID: 70004
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_blue
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 69991
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_blue
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.

ID: 70422
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_blue
Level 90
Isle of Thunder

ID: 69993
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_brown
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 70011
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_brown
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.

ID: 70005
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_dark
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 70008
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_dark
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.

ID: 69406
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_dark
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE

ID: 69148
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_dark
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Thunder
Troll rider despawns upon taming.

ID: 70006
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_green
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 70009
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_green
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.

ID: 70007
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_pale
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 70010
Look: zandalaridevilsaur_pale
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.
Direhorns

ID: 69992
Look: triceratopsblue
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 69983
Look: triceratopsblue
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.

ID: 70012
Look: triceratopsgreen
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 70016
Look: triceratopsgreen
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.

ID: 70013
Look: triceratopsorange
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 70017
Look: triceratopsorange
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.

ID: 70014
Look: triceratopsred
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 70018
Look: triceratopsred
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.

ID: 69193
Look: triceratopsred
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE

ID: 70015
Look: triceratopswhite
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Giants

ID: 69246
Look: triceratopswhite
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Thunder

ID: 70019
Look: triceratopswhite
Level 91 Elite
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.



ID: 70493
Look: triceratopsorange, triceratopsred, triceratopswhite
Level 90
Isle of Thunder




ID: 67576
Look: triceratopsblue, triceratopsgreen, triceratopsorange, triceratopswhite (haven't seen it in red but please let me know if it exists)
Level 90 Elite
Isle of Thunder




ID: 70059
Look: triceratopsblue, triceratopsgreen, triceratopsorange, triceratopsred
Level 90
Isle of Giants
NOT TAMEABLE - Friendly and caged.
Turtles

ID: 67703
Look: dragonturtleblueglow
Level 90
Isle of Thunder (Diremoor)

ID: 67763
Look: dragonturtleepicblueglow
Level 90
Isle of Thunder (Diremoor)

ID: 69998
Look: dragonturtleepicblueglow
Level 92 Rare Elite
Isle of Thunder (Diremoor)
NOT TAMEABLE - Flagged tameable, but level currently too high.
Crabs


ID: 69384
Look: deepseacrabbiolucentblue, deepseacrabbiolucentpurple
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
Raptors

ID: 69183
Look: ridingraptorskinobsidian
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE

ID: 70289
Look: raptorskinviolet
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE

ID: 69540
Look: raptorskinviolet
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE

ID: 69180
Look: pvpridingraptorskingreen
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE
Ridden by Zandalari Beastlords.

ID: 69306
Look: pvpridingraptorskinblack
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE
Ridden by Loa Speakers.
Goats



ID: 69523
Look: goatblack, goatblackspots, goatwhite
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
Carrion Birds

ID: 69349
Look: raven
Level 90
Isle of Thunder (Conqueror's Terrace)
Flees when attacked. You'll need to freeze it in place first.
Birds of Prey

ID: 70191
Look: browneagle
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE

ID: 70195
Look: snowyeagle
Level 90
Isle of Thunder
NOT TAMEABLE
Basilisks

ID: 69358
Look: basiliskskinburgundyorange_blue
Level 90
Isle of Thunder (Ihgaluk Crag)
NOT TAMEABLE - "Already controlled"
Dragonhawks

ID: 67676
Look: dragonhawkskin03
Level 90
Townlong Steppes (Shado-Pan Garrison)
NOT TAMEABLE
Worms
I've only included these larvae because of the two examples that are currently tameable even though that will end with 5.2. They'll still have to remain in the database:




ID: 69242
Look: larvaskindarkpurple, larvaskindarkred, larvaskinoutland, larvaskinoutlandpurple
Level 90
Isle of Thunder (Ihgaluk Crag)
NOT TAMEABLE
Spawn when Fetid Meat Piles attacked.