Hummm... of all my pets, the only one that needs an update is my bear, as all the rest are 'unique' in some way. While it would be cool if, say, Nthanda could get her own rare spawn and have it be the raven critter model, my bear needs the update most!
If I had to choose a pre existing tameable skin, he'd be a normal black bear and he'd spawn anywhere along the top of Duskwood, and with all the other black bears. Maybe a 3 hour spawn timer, like most lower level rares... He'd be neutral, but he'd be about 5 levels higher than all the surrounding mobs, and he'd hit like an elite ( and have the health of one, too! ), so that questing people won't accidentally kill him

And he'd be big! It's would take someone actively seeking him to bring him down, or rather, hopefully, tame him.
If I could choose an existing skin that is -not- tameable, I'd go for the black bear mount! I always imagine that my mount just happens to be my bear... In RP, he's that size, maybe bigger. Maybe he could switch spawning between the alliance and horde version? Some people will get him with blue armor, some with red!
Of course, if I could create my -own- bear, it would be like the worgen bear form- only pitch black, and none of the extra designs/trinkets. No bracers, no necklace, no druid symbol, none of that. Just a big, pitch black, worgen like bear. With long claws and glowing red-orange eyes :3
His name would be Taronyu, after my bear
