Little White Lies?
- Tufak
- Journeyman Hunter

- Posts: 246
- Joined: Sun Jul 10, 2011 11:18 am
- Realm: Feathermoon
- Gender: Male
- Contact:
Little White Lies?
So.
I have a friend that fancies himself a writer and he's earnest and sincere and tries really, really hard...but he's not very good at all. His grammar is atrocious, his spelling horrible and his sentence structure weak at best. He -tries- and you can tell that he's trying, but most of what he writes is on the same level as what you might expect from a fourth or fifth grader, despite his being of college age.
And, since I write, he comes to me regularly seeking praise.
I've attempted to work with him. I've had some progress. After somebody left a scathing review of one of his stories on DeviantArt that left him in tears, I managed to get some improvement from him by convincing him to stop capitalizing letters in places where there's no reason whatsoever to capitalize them (verbs, adjectives, nouns that weren't proper and were in the middle of the sentence). I got him to try changing his story structure from a 'And Then' status to a more flowing narrative.
But it seems as though he's reached another plateau. He's making no improvements, even with gentle advice. I certainly don't want to give him a scathing review like the one that was left before, but I have difficulty even reading one of his stories in full. And yet, after every post he makes, he asks me what I think.
So I lie. I say 'it was interesting' or I mention any one sentence that stood out in my mind as being better than others of what I read. I try to encourage him to continue writing, because I hope to see improvement with time and he does have good ideas, just no knack for implementation of them. I really don't like lying, though.
I'm almost to the end of my rope with it, particularly after his most recent piece that was posted this morning. I need advice on how to handle it all, I think and that's why I'm asking people here.
Should I continue the lies? Should I be frank and truthful? Or should I suggest that he find another person to help him?
What would you do?
I have a friend that fancies himself a writer and he's earnest and sincere and tries really, really hard...but he's not very good at all. His grammar is atrocious, his spelling horrible and his sentence structure weak at best. He -tries- and you can tell that he's trying, but most of what he writes is on the same level as what you might expect from a fourth or fifth grader, despite his being of college age.
And, since I write, he comes to me regularly seeking praise.
I've attempted to work with him. I've had some progress. After somebody left a scathing review of one of his stories on DeviantArt that left him in tears, I managed to get some improvement from him by convincing him to stop capitalizing letters in places where there's no reason whatsoever to capitalize them (verbs, adjectives, nouns that weren't proper and were in the middle of the sentence). I got him to try changing his story structure from a 'And Then' status to a more flowing narrative.
But it seems as though he's reached another plateau. He's making no improvements, even with gentle advice. I certainly don't want to give him a scathing review like the one that was left before, but I have difficulty even reading one of his stories in full. And yet, after every post he makes, he asks me what I think.
So I lie. I say 'it was interesting' or I mention any one sentence that stood out in my mind as being better than others of what I read. I try to encourage him to continue writing, because I hope to see improvement with time and he does have good ideas, just no knack for implementation of them. I really don't like lying, though.
I'm almost to the end of my rope with it, particularly after his most recent piece that was posted this morning. I need advice on how to handle it all, I think and that's why I'm asking people here.
Should I continue the lies? Should I be frank and truthful? Or should I suggest that he find another person to help him?
What would you do?
Where characters come to life...
http://homelyletters.livejournal.com/

My dragon babies: http://dragcave.net/user/Tufak
-
CrystalKitten
- Artisan Hunter

- Posts: 901
- Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2011 11:00 am
- Realm: Llane, Nesingwary
Re: Little White Lies?
It depends on how seriously he wants to take writing. I'm an artist of sorts (as a hobby, but I like to do just about everything, writing, drawing, painting, sculpting, digital 2d AND 3d, etc etc) and I can say there's NOTHING worse, when you're trying to improve yourself, than to be given "empty" praise. I learned at a very early age (like.. 7 or 8) not to ask my family what they thought of my work, because I KNEW it could be better, I knew the anatomical issues, etc, at least to some extent, and was always told "Omg! That's incredible!"... Even in later years when I was going to school for art, and so OBVIOUSLY needing criticism, I got the same responses from them, and my friends.
Out of curiosity, how much does he read? I consider myself a decent writer (I had my creative writing prof loving 2 of my stories in college, and he was notorious... fancied himself a big shot writer cause he's had some short stories published... They're up on my devart if anyone is interested http://crystalkitten.deviantart.com/gallery/ ), and I learned to write from reading since I was a kid. You could maybe suggest that he finds a series that he finds an author he really likes (preferably adult fiction, although, emulating a young adult writer might be an easier step), and just read read read. If he reads more, he'll get a feeling for what makes a good story, and how to make it flow. I would probably try and avoid any with strange formating for now (can't think of any books off the top of my head, but, for example, there's some books that do some "bad" practices as a literary tool, and some of that stuff might just confuse him). I would personally suggest Brandon Sanderson, if he's into fantasy. It's not too dry of a read, and he does some AMAZING things with a story line. Also, aside from Way of Kings, the Stormlight Archive, most of his books are stand-alones or trilogies. He also DOES have a young adult series, though I honestly haven't read it yet. But Sanderson is one of my new favourite authors. I would honestly say it'll probably be hard to be a good writer (especially with, as you seem to put it, his lack of skill with language, which could make up for everything if high enough) without reading a lot.
If he's serious with writing, I would continue giving him tips. Be honest, but try not to be too brutal. Don't candy coat TOO much, however, be sure to add extra emphasis on areas he's improved. I had some brutal reviews in college for my artwork.. and, the biggest suggestion I can say is NEVER say that something is "crap", even if it needs a LOT of work, say something diplomatic like.. "it just doesn't sound right... maybe if you _________" or "something here just feels awkward, maybe try __________".
Another option.. could be to partner him with someone who can rewrite some of his ideas (even just some paragraphs, and then let HIM rewrite the rest around it)... Not with the thought of stealing them... But with the idea of showing him what his stories COULD be if he improved. It'll either push him further, and help him see where to improve, or make him realize he's not cut out for writing. I might be willing to help a bit with this.. as it could be something to help me get back into writing my own stuff, but I can't guarantee anything, as classes start soon. PM me if interested.
Another big question is WHY does he want to write? Is it to be a big famous author? Does he even care about getting published? Is it just for friends and family, more or less? Does he simply feel the need to create and spread his ideas? Some of these reasons, if they are why he's in this hobby, might be reasons to try and gently coax him into other hobbies instead (if he's got no skill and just wants to be a big published writer to make money for "just writing"... it doesn't seem like it's gonna work). If it's just for himself, then who cares what the style is like? And he should be made aware of that. You could keep with your current level of advice, but because dramatic improvement isn't necessary... *shrug*. Could also try and steer him to other formats.. like children's books.
In short, IF encouraging him is the right thing to do, be honest, but diplomatic. Point him to other resources (there's probably hundreds of helpful sites out there, Brandon Sanderson, who I mentioned above, even does a podcast with some other writers about the process, to it's more advanced stuff, like magic systems, character development, etc), or get him to simply read more. And all those other ideas I said
But again, it all depends on WHY he's writing in the first place.
Out of curiosity, how much does he read? I consider myself a decent writer (I had my creative writing prof loving 2 of my stories in college, and he was notorious... fancied himself a big shot writer cause he's had some short stories published... They're up on my devart if anyone is interested http://crystalkitten.deviantart.com/gallery/ ), and I learned to write from reading since I was a kid. You could maybe suggest that he finds a series that he finds an author he really likes (preferably adult fiction, although, emulating a young adult writer might be an easier step), and just read read read. If he reads more, he'll get a feeling for what makes a good story, and how to make it flow. I would probably try and avoid any with strange formating for now (can't think of any books off the top of my head, but, for example, there's some books that do some "bad" practices as a literary tool, and some of that stuff might just confuse him). I would personally suggest Brandon Sanderson, if he's into fantasy. It's not too dry of a read, and he does some AMAZING things with a story line. Also, aside from Way of Kings, the Stormlight Archive, most of his books are stand-alones or trilogies. He also DOES have a young adult series, though I honestly haven't read it yet. But Sanderson is one of my new favourite authors. I would honestly say it'll probably be hard to be a good writer (especially with, as you seem to put it, his lack of skill with language, which could make up for everything if high enough) without reading a lot.
If he's serious with writing, I would continue giving him tips. Be honest, but try not to be too brutal. Don't candy coat TOO much, however, be sure to add extra emphasis on areas he's improved. I had some brutal reviews in college for my artwork.. and, the biggest suggestion I can say is NEVER say that something is "crap", even if it needs a LOT of work, say something diplomatic like.. "it just doesn't sound right... maybe if you _________" or "something here just feels awkward, maybe try __________".
Another option.. could be to partner him with someone who can rewrite some of his ideas (even just some paragraphs, and then let HIM rewrite the rest around it)... Not with the thought of stealing them... But with the idea of showing him what his stories COULD be if he improved. It'll either push him further, and help him see where to improve, or make him realize he's not cut out for writing. I might be willing to help a bit with this.. as it could be something to help me get back into writing my own stuff, but I can't guarantee anything, as classes start soon. PM me if interested.
Another big question is WHY does he want to write? Is it to be a big famous author? Does he even care about getting published? Is it just for friends and family, more or less? Does he simply feel the need to create and spread his ideas? Some of these reasons, if they are why he's in this hobby, might be reasons to try and gently coax him into other hobbies instead (if he's got no skill and just wants to be a big published writer to make money for "just writing"... it doesn't seem like it's gonna work). If it's just for himself, then who cares what the style is like? And he should be made aware of that. You could keep with your current level of advice, but because dramatic improvement isn't necessary... *shrug*. Could also try and steer him to other formats.. like children's books.
In short, IF encouraging him is the right thing to do, be honest, but diplomatic. Point him to other resources (there's probably hundreds of helpful sites out there, Brandon Sanderson, who I mentioned above, even does a podcast with some other writers about the process, to it's more advanced stuff, like magic systems, character development, etc), or get him to simply read more. And all those other ideas I said
- GormanGhaste
- Community Resource

- Posts: 6723
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2010 2:00 pm
- Realm: Uldaman (and Ravencrest)
Re: Little White Lies?
No, you shouldn't be lying to him about it, he's a friend, not some random person at a cocktail party. I would tell him he needs to spend more time on rewriting, if he wants to improve. Then offer him constructive suggestions about a particular piece. Then refuse to look at new works until he's done some decent editing on the previous one. If he doesn't show any interest in rewrites, then there really isn't any point in giving him any further encouragement.
And I agree with Crystal, you can't be a good writer unless you read, read, read.
And I agree with Crystal, you can't be a good writer unless you read, read, read.
-
Worba
- Illustrious Master Hunter

- Posts: 3522
- Joined: Wed Jul 28, 2010 3:56 pm
- Realm: Uther, Zangarmarsh, Shu'halo, Fenris, Quel'Thalas+
- Gender: Orc
- Location: In Sethekk Halls, bothering Anzu (90 runs and counting)
Re: Little White Lies?
And also research, research, research.
Even when writing in the fantasy genre, where research really *shouldn't* be (that) necessary... it still is. You can always tell which stories were researched and which ones weren't. The latter kind tend to blur together without much feeling of rhyme or reason, beyond that the writer wants it to happen that way.
To the OP: this isn't just about your friend, it's about YOUR feelings too. You say it bothers you to lie - then stop it. Have a frank conversation with him and let him know in general terms that if he wants more feedback going forward, you're happy to continue with the advice but you won't be dressing it up. Instead of "this part was kind of interesting", it will be "this part was kind of interesting, but the rest of the story didn't really work for me".
Even when writing in the fantasy genre, where research really *shouldn't* be (that) necessary... it still is. You can always tell which stories were researched and which ones weren't. The latter kind tend to blur together without much feeling of rhyme or reason, beyond that the writer wants it to happen that way.
To the OP: this isn't just about your friend, it's about YOUR feelings too. You say it bothers you to lie - then stop it. Have a frank conversation with him and let him know in general terms that if he wants more feedback going forward, you're happy to continue with the advice but you won't be dressing it up. Instead of "this part was kind of interesting", it will be "this part was kind of interesting, but the rest of the story didn't really work for me".
- Tufak
- Journeyman Hunter

- Posts: 246
- Joined: Sun Jul 10, 2011 11:18 am
- Realm: Feathermoon
- Gender: Male
- Contact:
Re: Little White Lies?
I'll suggest both reading more and researching to him.
I might point out to him that on HL I regularly spend an hour reading up on a topic before I write the story, which is why I have highly detailed stories there about armoursmithing, farrier work, arrow fletching, etc. I recently spent about two hours trying to decide what type of ship the Blood Elven style is and whether those would be useful for long distance merchant ships (they wouldn't), which resulted in my having to decide what type of ship would be used for long distance merchant vessels and therefore what sort of ship my pirate character sailed on, since he only likes to play at being a pirate and really is a fairly respectable merchant, despite the mechanical arm that makes others think differently...and so on and so forth.
Edit to add: All total the story that came from the research I mentioned took me six hours (counting the research) and I still don't like it. I did find, though, that the Alliance sailing ship is a Galleon, that the spurs jutting from the mast are called yards, that you 'heel' a ship by tightening the running ropes on the inside of a turn against belaying pins and that the rudder must be turned toward the direction you're turning away from to turn a ship.
The completed story after all that research is here: http://homelyletters.livejournal.com/247012.html
I might point out to him that on HL I regularly spend an hour reading up on a topic before I write the story, which is why I have highly detailed stories there about armoursmithing, farrier work, arrow fletching, etc. I recently spent about two hours trying to decide what type of ship the Blood Elven style is and whether those would be useful for long distance merchant ships (they wouldn't), which resulted in my having to decide what type of ship would be used for long distance merchant vessels and therefore what sort of ship my pirate character sailed on, since he only likes to play at being a pirate and really is a fairly respectable merchant, despite the mechanical arm that makes others think differently...and so on and so forth.
Edit to add: All total the story that came from the research I mentioned took me six hours (counting the research) and I still don't like it. I did find, though, that the Alliance sailing ship is a Galleon, that the spurs jutting from the mast are called yards, that you 'heel' a ship by tightening the running ropes on the inside of a turn against belaying pins and that the rudder must be turned toward the direction you're turning away from to turn a ship.
The completed story after all that research is here: http://homelyletters.livejournal.com/247012.html
Last edited by Tufak on Thu Aug 25, 2011 10:36 am, edited 1 time in total.
Where characters come to life...
http://homelyletters.livejournal.com/

My dragon babies: http://dragcave.net/user/Tufak
-
Worba
- Illustrious Master Hunter

- Posts: 3522
- Joined: Wed Jul 28, 2010 3:56 pm
- Realm: Uther, Zangarmarsh, Shu'halo, Fenris, Quel'Thalas+
- Gender: Orc
- Location: In Sethekk Halls, bothering Anzu (90 runs and counting)
Re: Little White Lies?
Yep. It sounds corny but most if not all the big stuff emerges from little stuff; writing action and romance scenes is easy - framing them into a larger cohesive picture is hard. As I found to my dismay. 
OP: reading, research, and honesty (in re: your actual feelings about the work he asks you to review). You might also suggest writer's workshops to him.
OP: reading, research, and honesty (in re: your actual feelings about the work he asks you to review). You might also suggest writer's workshops to him.
- Aeladrine
- Grand Master Hunter

- Posts: 2803
- Joined: Thu Jul 01, 2010 10:06 pm
- Realm: Frostwolf, Blackwater Raiders
- Gender: Female
- Location: Tumblr, probably.
- Contact:
Re: Little White Lies?
Everything that others have said is valuable. Follow it.
One other thing: I've found that one can be harsher if they make it a suggestion. Instead of marking up papers say, "Well, you see this bit here? It might work a bit better this way, this way, or this way. I generally wouldn't do this, I'd do this instead." Stuff like that. This is especially relevant because he respects you as an author; he's going to want to emulate you as best he can without doing an exact copy-cat.
Or, inversely, if this is already what you do, pull out the red pen. It is, of course, easier when it's not a friend to mark up a page so much that you can barely read the original writing, but it may be necessary. However, do not give your opinions on this, except for the things you liked. If you do this, let the edits speak for themselves. Because, honestly, if sounds like what this guy really needs is a good editor, not a friend to make him feel better. Being his editor, for the time being, will either allow him to grow as a writer or cause him to realize he's just not cut out for it or doesn't truly enjoy it and quit.
To your friend, a suggestion: if it's not flowing, don't force it. Get up and walk away. Once you get something that just pours out of you like literary barf onto your screen, nothing feels the same. Nothing is as good. You will always strive for it again. It will make you better. It will make you persistent, determined, and probably rather cranky, too. It's only ever happened to me once. One time in years and years of writing. In the months since, it hasn't come back. It will again, I know.
So just sit tight and wait for the Muses. You'll thank me in the morning.
One other thing: I've found that one can be harsher if they make it a suggestion. Instead of marking up papers say, "Well, you see this bit here? It might work a bit better this way, this way, or this way. I generally wouldn't do this, I'd do this instead." Stuff like that. This is especially relevant because he respects you as an author; he's going to want to emulate you as best he can without doing an exact copy-cat.
Or, inversely, if this is already what you do, pull out the red pen. It is, of course, easier when it's not a friend to mark up a page so much that you can barely read the original writing, but it may be necessary. However, do not give your opinions on this, except for the things you liked. If you do this, let the edits speak for themselves. Because, honestly, if sounds like what this guy really needs is a good editor, not a friend to make him feel better. Being his editor, for the time being, will either allow him to grow as a writer or cause him to realize he's just not cut out for it or doesn't truly enjoy it and quit.
To your friend, a suggestion: if it's not flowing, don't force it. Get up and walk away. Once you get something that just pours out of you like literary barf onto your screen, nothing feels the same. Nothing is as good. You will always strive for it again. It will make you better. It will make you persistent, determined, and probably rather cranky, too. It's only ever happened to me once. One time in years and years of writing. In the months since, it hasn't come back. It will again, I know.
So just sit tight and wait for the Muses. You'll thank me in the morning.
• Aela's Pet Journal
![]()
Totally fantastic avatars and signatures by Sookie, Nili, Serenith, and Kurenio.
Tumblr || Deviantart || WoW RP Blog


