Okay nobody here knows me... I've played every mmorpg, I swear lol... I've played WoW since it came out on and off as friends migrated between the various games, but I've always enjoyed the Hunter class...
I've had level 80 Hunter's and everything in between. The other day I was on my priest farming badges for my new Hunter's BOA gear and got into a long chat with a guy about Hunter's. I figured I could use the refresh since my old lvl 80 Hunter hadn't been played for six months. Sadly I just couldn't believe what I heard. We also have a guildie Hunter and he about said the exact same thing. First the spec tree's are even more out of whack and everyone just HAS to run a wolf now. I even heard this from a group leader a few days later. The conversation went something along these lines.
Group Leader : " ... Hunter..? Where's wolf pet..? "
Hunter : " ... I'm BM and use Devilsaur... "
Group Leader : " OMG..! You noob..! Hunter's have to run a wolf, everyone knows that..! "
Hunter : " ... What..? "
Hunter gets dropped sadly moments later...
Now, I sit back on my priest shaking my head. I know people have become way to taken in by forums and all the min / maxing BS, but damn... And, I keep hearing the name Ghostcrawler come up over and over... Sounds like a nice guy.

I don't know. I guess it's all about the Damage meters these days... I sure do miss the days of just completing a dungeon as job well done. I sat in front of my character screen the other day thinking about all the BOA items I had gathered for my new Hunter and what spec I should run. I'm one of those that tends to keep whatever spec I start with. Just weird like that. I went BM even after all the negative stuff floating around. I know at 80 I'll be shunned by the elitist and min/maxers, but I just don't care... I like the class and I like the pets. I want my pet as good as I can make them. If that means my DPS suffers, so be it... They can nerf the spec into the ground and I'll stubbornly hang on. I talked to our high end Hunter in guild after the last patch. The one that claimed BM got a slight buff and his DPS actually dropped. No idea why, but he had to respec to bring it back in line again.
This thing about Wolves being a have to have is getting old as well. I love the little guys, I truly do, but a must have..? I thought those days were supposed to be gone. "... We've normalized all the pets now... " Guess not... I have to agree with the idea of moving the howl into the Ferocity tree and giving Wolves a new ability. The idea of letting the Hunter pick his pets talent tree is the best idea I've heard as well. A Tenacity Eagle sounds good to me lol... Opens up so many options and players will never know what's coming at them in PvP. That cute little Sporebat might rip your face off...
Finally... I've heard the argument about BM pets and Hunter's losing huge chunks of DPS if they die. Ummm... So what..? I think we're all aware that our DPS is going to tank if that uber pet drops, but isn't that what the spec's all about..? That's the fate we signed up for by attaching ourselves so closely to our pets in the first place, right..? I for one understand the concept. My pet's doing a big chunk of my damage, need to watch the 'ol boy a bit close in this next fight. I gave up that MM personal damage for my pet, so I'll work extra hard to keep him up... I never blasted Blizzard for my talent choice in the past. I just paid more attention to Smokey the bear a bit more than my MM or Survival spec'd brethren... That arguments logic doesn't hold water for me. I'll gladly accept my DPS fall off if my buddy goes down.
The way BM use to be setup we had good constant damage. We sacrificed those really big numbers for it and our pet, but we filled a niche and most never complained except casters on the receiving end of a BW in a BG. I for one will remain BM no matter how bad times ever get. It's my personal playstyle. BM is about team work between Hunter and pet no matter how much people like Ghostcrawler might want it not to be. I know it's crazy getting so worked up over a spec line, but I do so get tired of the endless debate that others constantly express in dungeons, raids, forums and Blizzard panels... If they do continue to leech pet DPS and abilities away from the BM tree they really should call it something else...
Take Care, Roo...