Okay, now that that's out of the way.....I just need to vent, that's all. I don't really expect feedback of any type, so thank you to those of you that read this senseless drivel.
I'm torn. I've been craving Dragon Age: Origins, but I have no idea what I want to play as. I have a few achievements that I haven't gotten yet, and I'm trying to decide if I want to do a playthrough just to get those, or if I should just do what I want. But I don't know what I want!!! Hence the miserable flopping. I think I want to do a playthrough that I like, more than one solely based on achievements, since I plan to import it to DA2 and possibly DA3.
I was going to play a dual-wield rogue (human noble) and romance Alistair and do the whole king/queen thing, but I've already done that before. While it was a nice enough ending, I just don't know if I want to do it again. So then today, I was trying to think of what else I could do.
As far as achievements go, the main ones I'm missing that are feasible at this time are: mage to level 20; recruit Loghain (thereby recruiting all possible members across all playthroughs); side with werewolves; keep Anvil of the Void; sacrifice Alistair/self/Loghain; romance Zevran (thereby achieving all romances).
I mulled it around in my wee brain for most of the day today, and by the end of the night I had decided that I definitely want to romance Zevran. Aaaand that's about as far as I've gotten.

Being a tank, my party would be me, Zevran and Wynne, and then whoever else as a second damage person. I probably wouldn't use Alistair unless I specced him to 2H, and even then I'd probably use someone else; and I may ask him to marry Anora and then sacrifice him or something to get the achievement. As long as I don't let myself get too attached to him, I should be fine (there's no way I could let that happen if I'm romancing him, I'm too emotional for that). In this playthrough, I'd probably side with the templars (at the end of that quest line, so that I can make sure Wynne doesn't leave) and keep the Anvil of the Void. And as much as I'd like to side with the werewolves, if I'm dating Zevran I just don't think I have it in me to slay his people, even if their leader is in the wrong (in my eyes).
My second option was to be a healer mage. My party would then be me as the healer, Zevran again and Alistair as the tank, and then a second DPS. I always seem to take over for Wynne anyway in past playthroughs (no matter how anal I am with their combat tactics), and I don't mind healing. But...I dunno. I can't seem to stick with mages. I've probably tried them at least three times by now, and each time I get to about level 12 or so and just stop. I don't know if I find them boring or what.
I think ultimately what will end up happening is that I'll do two more playthroughs. This one I'll do half the achievements I'm missing, and then in the second playthrough I'll do the other half. The main reason I was even having this much difficulty was because I wanted a super-duper save file for DA3 when it comes out, so I wanted to make sure it was exactly what I want and perfect and all that. But then the other part of me wants to get some of these achievements, and I genuinely would like to see what happens with Zevran and some of the other story choices. After all, do I want to do another playthrough of crap I've already done (in most cases twice?). So I dunno what to do. Truth be told, I don't really know what I'd consider the "perfect" save file. I always thought it was me as queen and Alistar as king, but that seems almost...bland? I think I'm more of the wandering and adventuring type, not some stuffy queen in a stuffy castle.


I think the most fun I've had in a playthrough so far was when I played a male city elf warrior tank and romanced Leliana. Tanks are fun for me, I love getting in there and being nigh unstoppable, but that's also what I did in the last playthrough and I didn't know if I wanted to do it again. That's why I initially started out with a rogue. Then I decided I wanted to romance Zevran and I don't really need two rogues in a group (and I don't like archery, it's boring). Bah!
Hmm, after typing all this out, I think I have perhaps convinced myself to play the female human noble tank and do a few of the achievements, and save the rest for another playthrough.

And then in Dragon Age 2, I was going to be a warrior since I don't have that achievement yet, but now I'm wondering if I want to play a warrior twice in a row.

Thanks for reading (if anyone even survived that)!!! ^.^