Qraljar wrote:
Eh, at worst, that seems like a fairly mild contradiction. At best, it can be made to fit just easily. Remember that it's only Sabellian and his dragons, and that we have no conclusive answer as to if anything might be creeping in their mind. Really, though. Even if not, then that wouldn't change much, because Old Gods are not interconnected entities. They are similar, they have similar ways of going about corrupting organisms. But they're not the same. As such, if a corrupted creature were to leave Azeroth to escape the whispers, that process wouldn't continue on another planet with an Old God through the sheer fact that there is an Old God there. The Old God would have to make a conscious decision to want to take over the corruption that those on Azeroth started with.
Then there's also the possibility that the Old God in our universe is already dead. Remember that the Arakkoa were trying to summon one. Something that only really happens when an Old God has perished and been pushed out of our reality and defeated. This means that, in the alternate universe where we're going, it's still alive and kicking, with Arakkoa, Scorpar, Ravagers and Hook Wasps as their minions and/or creations, still following it.
Either way. If you are to make the case that the existence of an Old God on Draenor is impossible simply because the Black Dragons are corrupted, then you have to make the case that this Old God would be in contact with the Azerothian Old Gods and would deliberately follow up on the corruption of the Black Dragons that the Azeroth Old Gods started with. We have no indication of that. None of the Old Gods on Azeroth, who would be even more connected, at any time, felt any need to follow up on what one of their brethren was doing if it perished. Yogg-Saron didn't take over the Qiraji, nor the Mantid. Nor did N'Zoth or any other currently unnamed Old God.
Otherwise you have to make the case that an Old God corrupts anything, and therefore the Black Dragons should fall to corruption again as they're just one of the victims who conveniently made it into that list and already had an Old God history. This is observably untrue, as Azeroth holds many life-forms that the Old Gods have left alone for now, to focus on others that could be of more use to them. This Old God just so happened to have other priorities, another focus, and left the Black Dragons on Draenor alone, which can easily happen.
I can't help myself I love Old God lore.. so here goes XD
Old God's did not get along with each other. They warred with each other in fact. Millennia ago, Warlord Zon'ozz and his faceless soldiers waged endless war in the name of N'Zoth against the forces of C'Thun and Yogg-Saron. Now I am not sure if this fighting was universal throughout or if this was just N'Zoth vs those two or if it was a three way war. So would Old Gods take up the work of another? Possibly? But likely not.
The better question at hand is why do they corrupt not will they corrupt. On Azeroth we know the Old Gods invented the "Curse of Flesh" in reality a virus that turned the mechanical and stone constructs of the titans into beings of flesh. Why?
We know that this "Curse of Flesh" destabilized the matrix. Matrix in this sense refers to the body of the creatures inflicted; Earthen, Vykrul, Mechgnomes, Mogu, etc. But why destabilize the matrix? Why make them flesh? The Old Gods were restoring chaos that was replaced by the titans order. The titans did not create Azeroth, it was already there, they simply arrived and brought order to the place. But why did the Old Gods want to revert back to chaos? The fancy pants titan computers said to facilitate assimilation. So the Old Gods could feed off these creatures.
The Old Gods are responsible for all sentient life on Azeroth today save for what remains of the stone and metal constructs. Oh and a link between Trolls/Elves/Tauren/Goblins and the Old God's has yet to be found or established, it is possible that these races existed before the Titans arrived. But the Old God's are directly responsible for the existence of Humans, Dwarves, Gnomes, Troggs, and of course the Aqir which they evolved from Silithids.