I agree with both your points.Gimlion wrote:The whole "Kill a rare from under a tame, if stolen from you" Is a weird conflict in my mind. It seems only fair that the pet that was rightfully claimed by you, thus being tamed, getting stolen from you should resort in the other hunter getting theirs stolen/taken as well, an eye for an eye.
However, thinking about it more closely, I'd rather just let them get the tame. It overall means one less hunter looking for the same rare you are, and eases competition slightly.
I have had one encounter where I found skoll and had another hunter coming over to tame when an alli hunter came and started to tame. I did not attempt to kill the beast, but the alli hunter on the other hand. I tried to delay the alli so the hunter I had whispered could come and tame, but the graveyard was right by so no luck. The alli hunter got skoll, and I logged and made a lvl1alli-something to tell her I had someone coming over to tame, and then congratulates her. I also said I was happy skoll did not get killed.
Had the beast been for myself and I was midtame, I honestly don't know what I would have done. Either tried to pull the beast back to me, killed it, or let the other hunter have it.
I think for me it depends whether the player stealing the tame is of the same faction and if it's another hunter or some other class. That said, if it's a different class, there is no help. The beast would most likely end up dead anyway.
And to your point: 1) It would be nice with one less to compete with. On the other hand, new players will probably level up to the required level for this and that pet everyday, so it's not in our favour if you catch my drift. Some of them will be helpful and give a /w if they see a rare, and the other ones will be the griefers.
2) Why should we eventually let the other hunter keep taming the beast, when we both tagged and started the tame first? Of course, we can report, and put them out on websides. I know there is one mentioned in some other thread.
Hehe, sorry, my hands just took over this :p
It is surely a conflict in my mind too.